2011 Draft Prep: 12-team, mixed 5x5 mock draft
Listen to our latest Fantasy Baseball Podcast!
With opening day just a few weeks away, we thought it would be a good time to conduct our 12-team, in-house 5x5 Rotisserie draft for our readers to consume, learn from and, yes, ridicule.
We've gathered 12 of the sharpest Fantasy minds at CBSSports.com for our annual in-house, mixed-league, Roto draft which we will play out for department bragging rights in 2011.
Scoring for Batting Categories
Batting Average
Home Runs
Runs
Runs Batted In
Stolen Bases
Scoring for Pitching Categories
Earned Run Average
Strikeouts
Saves
Wins
WHIP
The owners and draft order ...
1. John Garcia, Jr., Fantasy Writer
2. Adam Aizer, Studio Host
3. Peter Madden, Editorial Director, Fantasy Sports
4. Kevin Goodwin, Fantasy Writer
5. Al Melchior, Data Analyst
6. Ed Gauna, Fantasy Writer
7. Bill Passonno, Fantasy Writer
8. Michael Hurcomb, Fantasy Writer
9. Ross Devonport, Senior Fantasy Writer
10. Jamey Eisenberg, Senior Fantasy Writer
11. Scott White, Fantasy Writer
12. Dave Richard, Senior Fantasy Writer
| Draft Results | ||
| Round 1 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | John Garcia Jr. | Albert Pujols, 1B, STL |
| 2 | Adam Aizer | Hanley Ramirez, SS, FLA |
| 3 | Peter Madden | Troy Tulowitzki, SS, COL |
| 4 | Kevin Goodwin | Robinson Cano, 2B, NYY |
| 5 | Al Melchior | Miguel Cabrera, 1B, DET |
| 6 | Ed Gauna | Joey Votto, 1B, CIN |
| 7 | Bill Passonno | Carl Crawford, LF, BOS |
| 8 | Michael Hurcomb | Carlos Gonzalez, LF, COL |
| 9 | Ross Devonport | Evan Longoria, 3B, TB |
| 10 | Jamey Eisenberg | Ryan Braun, LF, MIL |
| 11 | Scott White | Ryan Zimmerman, 3B, WAS |
| 12 | Dave Richard | Roy Halladay, SP, PHI |
| Round 2 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | Dave Richard | Joe Mauer, C, MIN |
| 2 | Scott White | Mark Teixeira, 1B, NYY |
| 3 | Jamey Eisenberg | Felix Hernandez, SP, SEA |
| 4 | Ross Devonport | Josh Hamilton, CF, TEX |
| 5 | Michael Hurcomb | David Wright, 3B, NYM |
| 6 | Bill Passonno | Prince Fielder, 1B, MIL |
| 7 | Ed Gauna | Alex Rodriguez, 3B, NYY |
| 8 | Al Melchior | Jose Bautista, LF, TOR |
| 9 | Kevin Goodwin | Adrian Gonzalez, 1B, BOS |
| 10 | Peter Madden | Dustin Pedroia, 2B, BOS |
| 11 | Adam Aizer | Kevin Youkilis, 1B, BOS |
| 12 | John Garcia Jr. | Jose Reyes, SS, NYM |
| Round 3 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | John Garcia Jr. | Tim Lincecum, SP, SF |
| 2 | Adam Aizer | Ryan Howard, 1B, PHI |
| 3 | Peter Madden | Cliff Lee, SP, PHI |
| 4 | Kevin Goodwin | CC Sabathia, SP, NYY |
| 5 | Al Melchior | Matt Holliday, LF, STL |
| 6 | Ed Gauna | Josh Johnson, SP, FLA |
| 7 | Bill Passonno | Buster Posey, C, SF |
| 8 | Michael Hurcomb | Victor Martinez, C, DET |
| 9 | Ross Devonport | Shin-Soo Choo, RF, CLE |
| 10 | Jamey Eisenberg | Ubaldo Jimenez, SP, COL |
| 11 | Scott White | Andrew McCutchen, CF, PIT |
| 12 | Dave Richard | Nelson Cruz, RF, TEX |
| Round 4 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | Dave Richard | Ian Kinsler, 2B, TEX |
| 2 | Scott White | Shane Victorino, CF, PHI |
| 3 | Jamey Eisenberg | Jacoby Ellsbury, CF, BOS |
| 4 | Ross Devonport | Jon Lester, SP, BOS |
| 5 | Michael Hurcomb | Justin Morneau, 1B, MIN |
| 6 | Bill Passonno | Matt Kemp, CF, LA |
| 7 | Ed Gauna | Ichiro Suzuki, RF, SEA |
| 8 | Al Melchior | Clayton Kershaw, SP, LA |
| 9 | Kevin Goodwin | Jason Heyward, RF, ATL |
| 10 | Peter Madden | Justin Upton, RF, ARI |
| 11 | Adam Aizer | Justin Verlander, SP, DET |
| 12 | John Garcia Jr. | Jayson Werth, RF, WAS |
| Round 5 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | John Garcia Jr. | David Price, SP, TB |
| 2 | Adam Aizer | Chris Young, CF, ARI |
| 3 | Peter Madden | Carlos Santana, C, CLE |
| 4 | Kevin Goodwin | Brian McCann, C, ATL |
| 5 | Al Melchior | Andre Ethier, RF, LA |
| 6 | Ed Gauna | Jered Weaver, SP, ANA |
| 7 | Bill Passonno | Kendry Morales, 1B, ANA |
| 8 | Michael Hurcomb | Dan Haren, SP, ANA |
| 9 | Ross Devonport | Cole Hamels, SP, PHI |
| 10 | Jamey Eisenberg | Dan Uggla, 2B, ATL |
| 11 | Scott White | Martin Prado, 2B, ATL |
| 12 | Dave Richard | Alex Rios, CF, CHW |
| Round 6 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | Dave Richard | Adam Dunn, 1B, CHW |
| 2 | Scott White | Chase Utley, 2B, PHI |
| 3 | Jamey Eisenberg | Jimmy Rollins, SS, PHI |
| 4 | Ross Devonport | Chris Carpenter, SP, STL |
| 5 | Michael Hurcomb | Rickie Weeks, 2B, MIL |
| 6 | Bill Passonno | Yovani Gallardo, SP, MIL |
| 7 | Ed Gauna | Brandon Phillips, 2B, CIN |
| 8 | Al Melchior | Matt Cain, SP, SF |
| 9 | Kevin Goodwin | B.J. Upton, CF, TB |
| 10 | Peter Madden | Brett Gardner, CF, NYY |
| 11 | Adam Aizer | Tommy Hanson, SP, ATL |
| 12 | John Garcia Jr. | Adrian Beltre, 3B, TEX |
| Round 7 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | John Garcia Jr. | Mike Stanton, RF, FLA |
| 2 | Adam Aizer | Hunter Pence, RF, HOU |
| 3 | Peter Madden | Billy Butler, 1B, KC |
| 4 | Kevin Goodwin | Elvis Andrus, SS, TEX |
| 5 | Al Melchior | Ben Zobrist, RF, TB |
| 6 | Ed Gauna | Nick Markakis, RF, BAL |
| 7 | Bill Passonno | Colby Rasmus, CF, STL |
| 8 | Michael Hurcomb | Paul Konerko, 1B, CHW |
| 9 | Ross Devonport | Derek Jeter, SS, NYY |
| 10 | Jamey Eisenberg | Brian Wilson, RP, SF |
| 11 | Scott White | Jay Bruce, RF, CIN |
| 12 | Dave Richard | Josh Beckett, SP, BOS |
| Round 8 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | Dave Richard | Stephen Drew, SS, ARI |
| 2 | Scott White | Drew Stubbs, CF, CIN |
| 3 | Jamey Eisenberg | Geovany Soto, C, CHC |
| 4 | Ross Devonport | Mariano Rivera, RP, NYY |
| 5 | Michael Hurcomb | Alexei Ramirez, SS, CHW |
| 6 | Bill Passonno | Zack Greinke, SP, MIL |
| 7 | Ed Gauna | Carlos Marmol, RP, CHC |
| 8 | Al Melchior | Curtis Granderson, CF, NYY |
| 9 | Kevin Goodwin | Casey McGehee, 3B, MIL |
| 10 | Peter Madden | Mat Latos, SP, SD |
| 11 | Adam Aizer | Francisco Liriano, SP, MIN |
| 12 | John Garcia Jr. | Brian Roberts, 2B, BAL |
| Round 9 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | John Garcia Jr. | Clay Buchholz, SP, BOS |
| 2 | Adam Aizer | Kelly Johnson, 2B, ARI |
| 3 | Peter Madden | Jonathan Sanchez, SP, SF |
| 4 | Kevin Goodwin | Heath Bell, RP, SD |
| 5 | Al Melchior | Rafael Furcal, SS, LA |
| 6 | Ed Gauna | Kurt Suzuki, C, OAK |
| 7 | Bill Passonno | Pablo Sandoval, 3B, SF |
| 8 | Michael Hurcomb | Roy Oswalt, SP, PHI |
| 9 | Ross Devonport | Matt Wieters, C, BAL |
| 10 | Jamey Eisenberg | Pedro Alvarez, 3B, PIT |
| 11 | Scott White | Max Scherzer, SP, DET |
| 12 | Dave Richard | Jonathan Papelbon, RP, BOS |
| Round 10 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | Dave Richard | Delmon Young, LF, MIN |
| 2 | Scott White | Daniel Hudson, SP, ARI |
| 3 | Jamey Eisenberg | Joakim Soria, RP, KC |
| 4 | Ross Devonport | Brett Anderson, SP, OAK |
| 5 | Michael Hurcomb | Mark Reynolds, 3B, BAL |
| 6 | Bill Passonno | Chad Billingsley, SP, LA |
| 7 | Ed Gauna | Neftali Feliz, RP, TEX |
| 8 | Al Melchior | Shaun Marcum, SP, MIL |
| 9 | Kevin Goodwin | Neil Walker, 2B, PIT |
| 10 | Peter Madden | Michael Bourn, CF, HOU |
| 11 | Adam Aizer | Trevor Cahill, SP, OAK |
| 12 | John Garcia Jr. | Juan Pierre, LF, CHW |
| Round 11 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | John Garcia Jr. | Colby Lewis, SP, TEX |
| 2 | Adam Aizer | Andrew Bailey, RP, OAK |
| 3 | Peter Madden | Brandon Morrow, SP, TOR |
| 4 | Kevin Goodwin | Vernon Wells, CF, ANA |
| 5 | Al Melchior | Miguel Montero, C, ARI |
| 6 | Ed Gauna | Starlin Castro, SS, CHC |
| 7 | Bill Passonno | John Danks, SP, CHW |
| 8 | Michael Hurcomb | Tim Hudson, SP, ATL |
| 9 | Ross Devonport | Gordon Beckham, 2B, CHW |
| 10 | Jamey Eisenberg | Phil Hughes, SP, NYY |
| 11 | Scott White | Brett Myers, SP, HOU |
| 12 | Dave Richard | Corey Hart, RF, MIL |
| Round 12 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | Dave Richard | Mike Napoli, 1B, TEX |
| 2 | Scott White | Nick Swisher, RF, NYY |
| 3 | Jamey Eisenberg | Aramis Ramirez, 3B, CHC |
| 4 | Ross Devonport | Angel Pagan, CF, NYM |
| 5 | Michael Hurcomb | Bobby Abreu, RF, ANA |
| 6 | Bill Passonno | Adam Jones, CF, BAL |
| 7 | Ed Gauna | Ryan Dempster, SP, CHC |
| 8 | Al Melchior | Jose Valverde, RP, DET |
| 9 | Kevin Goodwin | Francisco Rodriguez, RP, NYM |
| 10 | Peter Madden | Wandy Rodriguez, SP, HOU |
| 11 | Adam Aizer | Chone Figgins, 2B, SEA |
| 12 | John Garcia Jr. | Russell Martin, C, NYY |
| Round 13 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | John Garcia Jr. | Jonathan Broxton, RP, LA |
| 2 | Adam Aizer | Ted Lilly, SP, LA |
| 3 | Peter Madden | Adam Lind, DH, TOR |
| 4 | Kevin Goodwin | John Axford, RP, MIL |
| 5 | Al Melchior | Ian Kennedy, SP, ARI |
| 6 | Ed Gauna | Michael Young, 3B, TEX |
| 7 | Bill Passonno | Brad Lidge, RP, PHI |
| 8 | Michael Hurcomb | Huston Street, RP, COL |
| 9 | Ross Devonport | Jeremy Hellickson, RP, TB |
| 10 | Jamey Eisenberg | John Lackey, SP, BOS |
| 11 | Scott White | J.J. Putz, RP, ARI |
| 12 | Dave Richard | Chris Johnson, 3B, HOU |
| Round 14 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | Dave Richard | Tsuyoshi Nishioka, 2B, MIN |
| 2 | Scott White | Chris Perez, RP, CLE |
| 3 | Jamey Eisenberg | Gaby Sanchez, 1B, FLA |
| 4 | Ross Devonport | Joe Nathan, RP, MIN |
| 5 | Michael Hurcomb | Jason Bay, LF, NYM |
| 6 | Bill Passonno | Aaron Hill, 2B, TOR |
| 7 | Ed Gauna | Ricky Romero, SP, TOR |
| 8 | Al Melchior | Aubrey Huff, 1B, SF |
| 9 | Kevin Goodwin | Carlos Lee, LF, HOU |
| 10 | Peter Madden | Carlos Quentin, LF, CHW |
| 11 | Adam Aizer | Jorge Posada, C, NYY |
| 12 | John Garcia Jr. | Madison Bumgarner, SP, SF |
| Round 15 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | John Garcia Jr. | Chris Coghlan, LF, FLA |
| 2 | Adam Aizer | C.J. Wilson, SP, TEX |
| 3 | Peter Madden | Matt Garza, SP, CHC |
| 4 | Kevin Goodwin | Jaime Garcia, SP, STL |
| 5 | Al Melchior | Michael Cuddyer, 1B, MIN |
| 6 | Ed Gauna | Logan Morrison, LF, FLA |
| 7 | Bill Passonno | Gio Gonzalez, SP, OAK |
| 8 | Michael Hurcomb | Craig Kimbrel, RP, ATL |
| 9 | Ross Devonport | Ike Davis, 1B, NYM |
| 10 | Jamey Eisenberg | David Ortiz, DH, BOS |
| 11 | Scott White | Jose Tabata, LF, PIT |
| 12 | Dave Richard | Edwin Jackson, SP, CHW |
| Round 16 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | Dave Richard | Miguel Tejada, 3B, SF |
| 2 | Scott White | Edinson Volquez, SP, CIN |
| 3 | Jamey Eisenberg | Yunel Escobar, SS, TOR |
| 4 | Ross Devonport | Austin Jackson, CF, DET |
| 5 | Michael Hurcomb | Rajai Davis, CF, TOR |
| 6 | Bill Passonno | Ian Desmond, SS, WAS |
| 7 | Ed Gauna | Francisco Cordero, RP, CIN |
| 8 | Al Melchior | Coco Crisp, CF, OAK |
| 9 | Kevin Goodwin | Ervin Santana, SP, ANA |
| 10 | Peter Madden | David Freese, 3B, STL |
| 11 | Adam Aizer | Matt Thornton, RP, CHW |
| 12 | John Garcia Jr. | Torii Hunter, CF, ANA |
| Round 17 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | John Garcia Jr. | Juan Uribe, SS, LA |
| 2 | Adam Aizer | Andres Torres, CF, SF |
| 3 | Peter Madden | |
| 4 | Kevin Goodwin | Raul Ibanez, LF, PHI |
| 5 | Al Melchior | Leo Nunez, RP, FLA |
| 6 | Ed Gauna | Luke Scott, DH, BAL |
| 7 | Bill Passonno | Grady Sizemore, CF, CLE |
| 8 | Michael Hurcomb | Carlos Zambrano, SP, CHC |
| 9 | Ross Devonport | Freddie Freeman, 1B, ATL |
| 10 | Jamey Eisenberg | Johnny Cueto, SP, CIN |
| 11 | Scott White | Carlos Pena, 1B, CHC |
| 12 | Dave Richard | Jake Peavy, SP, CHW |
| Round 18 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | Dave Richard | Denard Span, CF, MIN |
| 2 | Scott White | Joel Hanrahan, RP, PIT |
| 3 | Jamey Eisenberg | Carlos Beltran, CF, NYM |
| 4 | Ross Devonport | Yadier Molina, C, STL |
| 5 | Michael Hurcomb | Brandon Lyon, RP, HOU |
| 6 | Bill Passonno | Howard Kendrick, 2B, ANA |
| 7 | Ed Gauna | Danny Espinosa, 2B, WAS |
| 8 | Al Melchior | Ricky Nolasco, SP, FLA |
| 9 | Kevin Goodwin | Anibal Sanchez, SP, FLA |
| 10 | Peter Madden | Travis Snider, LF, TOR |
| 11 | Adam Aizer | Ian Stewart, 3B, COL |
| 12 | John Garcia Jr. | Ryan Franklin, RP, STL |
| Round 19 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | John Garcia Jr. | Jason Bartlett, SS, SD |
| 2 | Adam Aizer | Magglio Ordonez, RF, DET |
| 3 | Peter Madden | Eric Young, 2B, COL |
| 4 | Kevin Goodwin | James Loney, 1B, LA |
| 5 | Al Melchior | Hiroki Kuroda, SP, LA |
| 6 | Ed Gauna | Javier Vazquez, SP, FLA |
| 7 | Bill Passonno | Asdrubal Cabrera, SS, CLE |
| 8 | Michael Hurcomb | Jair Jurrjens, SP, ATL |
| 9 | Ross Devonport | Manny Ramirez, LF, TB |
| 10 | Jamey Eisenberg | Chris Iannetta, C, COL |
| 11 | Scott White | Travis Wood, SP, CIN |
| 12 | Dave Richard | James Shields, SP, TB |
| Round 20 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | Dave Richard | Fernando Rodney, RP, ANA |
| 2 | Scott White | Brian Matusz, SP, BAL |
| 3 | Jamey Eisenberg | Cody Ross, CF, SF |
| 4 | Ross Devonport | Vladimir Guerrero, DH, BAL |
| 5 | Michael Hurcomb | Jhoulys Chacin, SP, COL |
| 6 | Bill Passonno | Josh Thole, C, NYM |
| 7 | Ed Gauna | Alfonso Soriano, LF, CHC |
| 8 | Al Melchior | A.J. Pierzynski, C, CHW |
| 9 | Kevin Goodwin | Bronson Arroyo, SP, CIN |
| 10 | Peter Madden | Gavin Floyd, SP, CHW |
| 11 | Adam Aizer | Domonic Brown, RF, PHI |
| 12 | John Garcia Jr. | Derrek Lee, 1B, BAL |
| Round 21 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | John Garcia Jr. | Carlos Ruiz, C, PHI |
| 2 | Adam Aizer | J.A. Happ, SP, HOU |
| 3 | Peter Madden | Drew Storen, RP, WAS |
| 4 | Kevin Goodwin | A.J. Burnett, SP, NYY |
| 5 | Al Melchior | Dexter Fowler, CF, COL |
| 6 | Ed Gauna | John Buck, C, FLA |
| 7 | Bill Passonno | Fausto Carmona, SP, CLE |
| 8 | Michael Hurcomb | Mike Aviles, 2B, KC |
| 9 | Ross Devonport | David Aardsma, RP, SEA |
| 10 | Jamey Eisenberg | Jordan Zimmermann, SP, WAS |
| 11 | Scott White | Jarrod Saltalamacchia, C, BOS |
| 12 | Dave Richard | Julio Borbon, CF, TEX |
| Round 22 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | Dave Richard | Jeff Niemann, SP, TB |
| 2 | Scott White | J.P. Arencibia, C, TOR |
| 3 | Jamey Eisenberg | Nyjer Morgan, CF, WAS |
| 4 | Ross Devonport | Koji Uehara, RP, BAL |
| 5 | Michael Hurcomb | John Jaso, C, TB |
| 6 | Bill Passonno | Kevin Gregg, RP, BAL |
| 7 | Ed Gauna | Carl Pavano, SP, MIN |
| 8 | Al Melchior | Jed Lowrie, 2B, BOS |
| 9 | Kevin Goodwin | Adam LaRoche, 1B, WAS |
| 10 | Peter Madden | Garrett Jones, 1B, PIT |
| 11 | Adam Aizer | David DeJesus, LF, OAK |
| 12 | John Garcia Jr. | Octavio Dotel, RP, TOR |
| Round 23 | ||
| Pick | Team | Player |
| 1 | John Garcia Jr. | Matt Capps, RP, MIN |
| 2 | Adam Aizer | Chris Snyder, C, PIT |
| 3 | Peter Madden | Alex Avila, C, DET |
| 4 | Kevin Goodwin | Miguel Olivo, C, SEA |
| 5 | Al Melchior | Jonathon Niese, SP, NYM |
| 6 | Ed Gauna | Peter Bourjos, CF, ANA |
| 7 | Bill Passonno | Erik Bedard, SP, SEA |
| 8 | Michael Hurcomb | Will Venable, RF, SD |
| 9 | Ross Devonport | Cliff Pennington, SS, OAK |
| 10 | Jamey Eisenberg | Mike Pelfrey, SP, NYM |
| 11 | Scott White | Alcides Escobar, SS, KC |
| 12 | Dave Richard | Frank Francisco, RP, TOR |