2012 Draft Prep: American League 5x5 auction
A 12-team, AL-only Rotisserie league is about as deep as it gets in Fantasy, and as you might expect, the bidding behavior changes as a result.
|
|
|
|
 |
Not a single player reached the $40 threshold in this auction. In fact, the elite players all went for less than you'd generally see in a mixed league. Did we get it backward? Not really. In mixed leagues, you can afford to take a studs-and-duds approach -- shelling out $45 and $50 for the best of the best and filling out the rest of your roster with $1 and $2 sleepers -- because you know that if those sleepers don't pan out, you'll still find plenty of fallback options on the waiver wire.
But in a league this deep, there are no fallback options. What you draft is what you get, which means you're better off not taking so many chances. The more evenly you spread your money, the better you'll be able to survive whatever misfortunes come your way over the 162-game grind.
As usual, the dollar values here don't necessarily match up with the rankings. Timing and shortages (either at a position or within a category) explain why Brett Gardner went for $28 while Josh Hamilton only went for only $24. In general, steals were in short supply in this auction, leading to inflated price tags for players like Gardner, B.J. Upton ($30), Alejandro De Aza ($17) and Ben Revere ($13).
Scoring for Batting Categories
BA - Batting Average
HR - Home Runs
R - Runs
RBI - Runs Batted In
SB - Stolen Bases
Pitching Categories
ERA - Earned Run Average
K - Strikeouts (Pitcher)
S - Saves
W - Wins
WHIP - Walks + Hits / Inning
The owners ...
1. Tom Kephart, Baseball HQ
2. Mike Gianella, Patton & Co.
3. Jeff Boggis, FantasySportsEmpires.com
4. Al Melchior, CBSSports.com
5. Scott Pianowski, Yahoo! Sports
6. Jamey Eisenberg, CBSSports.com
7. Scott White, CBSSports.com
8. Ryan Carey, Mastersball.com
9. Grey Albright and Rudy Gamble, Razzball
10. Derek Carty, Baseball Prospectus
11. Mike Kuchera, FanDuel.com
12. Dean Peterson, Stats LLC
Editor's note: Utilize the sortable functionality to get a sense of the auction. View by team, dollar amount and position.
Have a take on our latest auction results? Share your thoughts on our Fantasy Baseball Facebook page and on our Twitter feed @CBSFantasyBB !
| 2012 AL-only Fantasy Auction Draft (sortable) | ||||
| Order | Player | Pos | Price | Bid Won by |
| 3 | Miguel Cabrera, DET | 1B | $39 | Baseball HQ |
| 2 | Albert Pujols, LAA | 1B | $39 | FanDuel.com |
| 13 | Jose Bautista, TOR | OF | $38 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 14 | Curtis Granderson, NYY | OF | $36 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 11 | Adrian Gonzalez, BOS | 1B | $36 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 10 | Jacoby Ellsbury, BOS | OF | $35 | Patton & Co |
| 16 | Evan Longoria, TB | 3B | $33 | Razzball |
| 4 | Robinson Cano, NYY | 2B | $33 | Mastersball.com |
| 20 | Dustin Pedroia, BOS | 2B | $32 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 18 | Prince Fielder, DET | 1B | $31 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 62 | Adrian Beltre, TEX | 3B | $30 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 53 | Brett Lawrie, TOR | 3B | $30 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 37 | B.J. Upton, TB | OF | $30 | Baseball HQ |
| 9 | Justin Verlander, DET | P | $30 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 78 | Adam Jones, BAL | OF | $29 | Baseball HQ |
| 23 | Mark Teixeira, NYY | 1B | $29 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 61 | Brett Gardner, NYY | OF | $28 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 29 | Eric Hosmer, KC | 1B | $28 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 22 | Ian Kinsler, TEX | 2B | $28 | Stats LLC |
| 21 | Jered Weaver, LAA | P | $28 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 41 | Carlos Santana, CLE | C | $27 | Mastersball.com |
| 64 | Matt Wieters, BAL | C | $26 | Baseball HQ |
| 46 | Desmond Jennings, TB | OF | $26 | Stats LLC |
| 34 | David Price, TB | P | $26 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 49 | Shin-Soo Choo, CLE | OF | $25 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 47 | Elvis Andrus, TEX | SS | $25 | Mastersball.com |
| 33 | Dan Haren, LAA | P | $25 | Patton & Co |
| 28 | Felix Hernandez, SEA | P | $25 | Mastersball.com |
| 26 | Nelson Cruz, TEX | OF | $25 | Stats LLC |
| 42 | Alex Rodriguez, NYY | 3B | $24 | FanDuel.com |
| 30 | Ben Zobrist, TB | 2B | $24 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 6 | Josh Hamilton, TEX | OF | $24 | Patton & Co |
| 1 | CC Sabathia, NYY | P | $24 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 70 | Alex Gordon, KC | OF | $23 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 57 | Ichiro Suzuki, SEA | OF | $23 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 5 | Carl Crawford, BOS | OF | $23 | Patton & Co |
| 81 | Michael Young, TEX | 3B | $22 | Mastersball.com |
| 51 | Jon Lester, BOS | P | $22 | FanDuel.com |
| 45 | Asdrubal Cabrera, CLE | SS | $22 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 38 | Howard Kendrick, LAA | 2B | $22 | Patton & Co |
| 147 | Brennan Boesch, DET | OF | $21 | Mastersball.com |
| 89 | Ricky Romero, TOR | P | $21 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 56 | Paul Konerko, CHW | 1B | $21 | Patton & Co |
| 50 | Mariano Rivera, NYY | P | $21 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 44 | James Shields, TB | P | $21 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 27 | Mike Napoli, TEX | C | $21 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 25 | Alexei Ramirez, CHW | SS | $21 | Razzball |
| 77 | Nick Swisher, NYY | OF | $20 | Razzball |
| 74 | C.J. Wilson, LAA | P | $20 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 66 | Delmon Young, DET | OF | $20 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 54 | Kevin Youkilis, BOS | 3B | $20 | Baseball HQ |
| 135 | Peter Bourjos, LAA | OF | $19 | Baseball HQ |
| 110 | Alex Avila, DET | C | $19 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 105 | Nick Markakis, BAL | OF | $19 | Razzball |
| 97 | Mark Reynolds, BAL | 3B | $19 | Razzball |
| 91 | Erick Aybar, LAA | SS | $19 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 76 | Jeff Francoeur, KC | OF | $19 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 75 | Jose Valverde, DET | P | $19 | Mastersball.com |
| 43 | Jordan Walden, LAA | P | $19 | Stats LLC |
| 35 | Billy Butler, KC | DH | $19 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 7 | Sergio Santos, TOR | P | $19 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 106 | David Ortiz, BOS | DH | $18 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 93 | J.J. Hardy, BAL | SS | $18 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 88 | Jesus Montero, SEA | C | $18 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 80 | Joakim Soria, KC | P | $18 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 69 | Derek Jeter, NYY | SS | $18 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 68 | Michael Pineda, NYY | P | $18 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 65 | Brandon Morrow, TOR | P | $18 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 8 | Yu Darvish, TEX | P | $18 | FanDuel.com |
| 145 | Alejandro De Aza, CHW | OF | $17 | FanDuel.com |
| 73 | Ubaldo Jimenez, CLE | P | $17 | Stats LLC |
| 72 | Joe Nathan, TEX | P | $17 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 67 | Austin Jackson, DET | OF | $17 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 63 | Josh Beckett, BOS | P | $17 | FanDuel.com |
| 58 | Coco Crisp, OAK | OF | $17 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 31 | Dustin Ackley, SEA | 2B | $17 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 17 | Matt Moore, TB | P | $17 | Baseball HQ |
| 12 | Andrew Bailey, BOS | P | $17 | Stats LLC |
| 129 | Matt Joyce, TB | OF | $16 | Stats LLC |
| 116 | Max Scherzer, DET | P | $16 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 113 | Josh Willingham, MIN | OF | $16 | Baseball HQ |
| 109 | Adam Lind, TOR | 1B | $16 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 108 | Torii Hunter, LAA | OF | $16 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 85 | Alex Rios, CHW | OF | $16 | Mastersball.com |
| 84 | Brandon League, SEA | P | $16 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 15 | Joe Mauer, MIN | C | $16 | Patton & Co |
| 102 | Mike Moustakas, KC | 3B | $15 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 100 | Derek Holland, TEX | P | $15 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 99 | Kyle Farnsworth, TB | P | $15 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 94 | Yunel Escobar, TOR | SS | $15 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 82 | Jhonny Peralta, DET | SS | $15 | Baseball HQ |
| 60 | Kelly Johnson, TOR | 2B | $15 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 40 | Jason Kipnis, CLE | 2B | $15 | Patton & Co |
| 32 | Jemile Weeks, OAK | 2B | $15 | Patton & Co |
| 214 | Mike Carp, SEA | 1B | $14 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 164 | Colby Lewis, TEX | P | $14 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 163 | Dayan Viciedo, CHW | OF | $14 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 149 | John Danks, CHW | P | $14 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 125 | Scott Baker, MIN | P | $14 | Baseball HQ |
| 124 | Edwin Encarnacion, TOR | 3B | $14 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 119 | Denard Span, MIN | OF | $14 | FanDuel.com |
| 92 | Ervin Santana, LAA | P | $14 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 90 | Neftali Feliz, TEX | P | $14 | Stats LLC |
| 87 | Chris Perez, CLE | P | $14 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 86 | Jeremy Hellickson, TB | P | $14 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 59 | Ryan Doumit, MIN | C | $14 | FanDuel.com |
| 161 | Yoenis Cespedes, OAK | OF | $13 | Razzball |
| 123 | Justin Masterson, CLE | P | $13 | Razzball |
| 114 | Doug Fister, DET | P | $13 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 107 | Matt Thornton, CHW | P | $13 | FanDuel.com |
| 103 | Ben Revere, MIN | OF | $13 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 98 | Brandon McCarthy, OAK | P | $13 | Mastersball.com |
| 96 | Matt Capps, MIN | P | $13 | Mastersball.com |
| 83 | Michael Brantley, CLE | OF | $13 | Razzball |
| 157 | J.P. Arencibia, TOR | C | $12 | Stats LLC |
| 131 | Chris Sale, CHW | P | $12 | Razzball |
| 130 | Colby Rasmus, TOR | OF | $12 | Patton & Co |
| 118 | Alcides Escobar, KC | SS | $12 | Stats LLC |
| 112 | Lorenzo Cain, KC | OF | $12 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 104 | Jim Johnson, BAL | P | $12 | Razzball |
| 95 | Jarrod Saltalamacchia, BOS | C | $12 | FanDuel.com |
| 160 | Justin Smoak, SEA | 1B | $11 | Stats LLC |
| 159 | Russell Martin, NYY | C | $11 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 144 | Brent Morel, CHW | 3B | $11 | Stats LLC |
| 134 | Daniel Bard, BOS | P | $11 | FanDuel.com |
| 122 | Adam Dunn, CHW | 1B | $11 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 121 | Carlos Pena, TB | 1B | $11 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 111 | Clay Buchholz, BOS | P | $11 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 36 | Ryan Raburn, DET | OF | $11 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 140 | Chris Davis, BAL | 1B | $10 | FanDuel.com |
| 137 | Hiroki Kuroda, NYY | P | $10 | FanDuel.com |
| 136 | Cliff Pennington, OAK | SS | $10 | Patton & Co |
| 132 | Lonnie Chisenhall, CLE | 3B | $10 | Patton & Co |
| 101 | Francisco Liriano, MIN | P | $10 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 196 | Jamey Carroll, MIN | 2B | $9 | FanDuel.com |
| 178 | Nolan Reimold, BAL | OF | $9 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 177 | Alexi Casilla, MIN | 2B | $9 | Razzball |
| 162 | Chris Iannetta, LAA | C | $9 | Razzball |
| 153 | Mitch Moreland, TEX | 1B | $9 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 150 | Henderson Alvarez, TOR | P | $9 | Mastersball.com |
| 139 | Jonathan Sanchez, KC | P | $9 | Mastersball.com |
| 128 | Kurt Suzuki, OAK | C | $9 | Baseball HQ |
| 120 | Sean Rodriguez, TB | SS | $9 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 117 | Kendrys Morales, LAA | 1B | $9 | Stats LLC |
| 48 | Gordon Beckham, CHW | 2B | $9 | Stats LLC |
| 171 | Jake Peavy, CHW | P | $8 | Razzball |
| 166 | Gavin Floyd, CHW | P | $8 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 165 | Eric Thames, TOR | OF | $8 | Razzball |
| 142 | Vernon Wells, LAA | OF | $8 | Patton & Co |
| 127 | Mike Aviles, BOS | 3B | $8 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 126 | Ivan Nova, NYY | P | $8 | Razzball |
| 79 | Matt Harrison, TEX | P | $8 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 71 | Grady Sizemore, CLE | OF | $8 | FanDuel.com |
| 24 | Johnny Giavotella, KC | 2B | $8 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 213 | Brendan Ryan, SEA | SS | $7 | Razzball |
| 208 | Danny Valencia, MIN | 3B | $7 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 194 | Jason Vargas, SEA | P | $7 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 189 | Eduardo Nunez, NYY | SS | $7 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 158 | Addison Reed, CHW | P | $7 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 154 | Miguel Olivo, SEA | C | $7 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 151 | Franklin Gutierrez, SEA | OF | $7 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 133 | Phil Hughes, NYY | P | $7 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 55 | Mike Trout, LAA | OF | $7 | Stats LLC |
| 52 | Mark Trumbo, LAA | 1B | $7 | Mastersball.com |
| 39 | Justin Morneau, MIN | 1B | $7 | Razzball |
| 216 | Zach Britton, BAL | P | $6 | Stats LLC |
| 183 | A.J. Pierzynski, CHW | C | $6 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 180 | Josh Reddick, OAK | OF | $6 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 172 | Trevor Plouffe, MIN | SS | $6 | FanDuel.com |
| 170 | Brian Fuentes, OAK | P | $6 | Razzball |
| 168 | Jeff Niemann, TB | P | $6 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 167 | Luke Hochevar, KC | P | $6 | Patton & Co |
| 156 | Seth Smith, OAK | OF | $6 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 212 | David Robertson, NYY | P | $5 | Razzball |
| 202 | Grant Balfour, OAK | P | $5 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 190 | David Murphy, TEX | OF | $5 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 188 | Philip Humber, CHW | P | $5 | Patton & Co |
| 176 | Travis Snider, TOR | OF | $5 | Stats LLC |
| 174 | Wade Davis, TB | P | $5 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 169 | Salvador Perez, KC | C | $5 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 155 | Casey Kotchman, CLE | 1B | $5 | Patton & Co |
| 141 | Chone Figgins, SEA | 3B | $5 | Mastersball.com |
| 115 | Rajai Davis, TOR | OF | $5 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 247 | Francisco Cordero, TOR | P | $4 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 227 | Raul Ibanez, NYY | OF | $4 | Baseball HQ |
| 221 | Brian Matusz, BAL | P | $4 | FanDuel.com |
| 217 | Scott Sizemore, OAK | 3B | $4 | Baseball HQ |
| 200 | Alexi Ogando, TEX | P | $4 | Mastersball.com |
| 195 | Yorvit Torrealba, TEX | C | $4 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 193 | Maicer Izturis, LAA | 2B | $4 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 191 | Rick Porcello, DET | P | $4 | FanDuel.com |
| 184 | Brad Peacock, OAK | P | $4 | Razzball |
| 182 | Josh Tomlin, CLE | P | $4 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 181 | Brian Roberts, BAL | 2B | $4 | FanDuel.com |
| 173 | Felipe Paulino, KC | P | $4 | Stats LLC |
| 152 | Brent Lillibridge, CHW | OF | $4 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 143 | Alberto Callaspo, LAA | 3B | $4 | Razzball |
| 138 | Bobby Abreu, LAA | OF | $4 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 244 | Andy Dirks, DET | OF | $3 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 241 | Leonys Martin, TEX | OF | $3 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 236 | Ramon Santiago, DET | 2B | $3 | Baseball HQ |
| 230 | Craig Gentry, TEX | OF | $3 | Mastersball.com |
| 225 | Luke Scott, TB | OF | $3 | Baseball Prospectus |
| 211 | Jarrod Parker, OAK | P | $3 | Stats LLC |
| 206 | Bartolo Colon, OAK | P | $3 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 204 | Tyler Flowers, CHW | C | $3 | Stats LLC |
| 201 | Jose Molina, TB | C | $3 | Razzball |
| 198 | Ryan Sweeney, BOS | OF | $3 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 187 | Fautino De Los Santos, OAK | P | $3 | Stats LLC |
| 185 | Aaron Crow, KC | P | $3 | Razzball |
| 148 | Wei-Yin Chen, BAL | P | $3 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 19 | Wilson Betemit, BAL | 3B | $3 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 252 | Jeff Keppinger, TB | 2B | $2 | Mastersball.com |
| 240 | Robert Andino, BAL | 2B | $2 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 234 | Jacob Turner, DET | P | $2 | Baseball HQ |
| 232 | Cody Ross, BOS | OF | $2 | Baseball HQ |
| 229 | Mike Adams, TEX | P | $2 | Baseball HQ |
| 228 | Jesse Crain, CHW | P | $2 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 224 | Mark Melancon, BOS | P | $2 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 223 | Joey Devine, OAK | P | $2 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 219 | Brett Cecil, TOR | P | $2 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 218 | Alfredo Aceves, BOS | P | $2 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 215 | Joaquin Benoit, DET | P | $2 | Baseball HQ |
| 210 | Kyle Seager, SEA | 3B | $2 | Stats LLC |
| 209 | Danny Duffy, KC | P | $2 | Baseball HQ |
| 207 | Hideki Matsui, OAK | OF | $2 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 203 | Chris Getz, KC | 2B | $2 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 179 | Bruce Chen, KC | P | $2 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 175 | Kevin Slowey, CLE | P | $2 | Baseball HQ |
| 146 | Carl Pavano, MIN | P | $2 | Mastersball.com |
| 276 | Fausto Carmona, CLE | P | $1 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 275 | Nick Blackburn, MIN | P | $1 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 274 | Brian Duensing, MIN | P | $1 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 273 | Magglio Ordonez, DET | OF | $1 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 272 | Brandon Inge, DET | 3B | $1 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 271 | Greg Holland, KC | P | $1 | Patton & Co |
| 270 | Julio Borbon, TEX | OF | $1 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 269 | Joel Peralta, TB | P | $1 | Patton & Co |
| 268 | Sam Fuld, TB | OF | $1 | Mastersball.com |
| 267 | Don Kelly, DET | OF | $1 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 266 | Yuniesky Betancourt, KC | SS | $1 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 265 | Glen Perkins, MIN | P | $1 | Patton & Co |
| 264 | Endy Chavez, BAL | OF | $1 | Mastersball.com |
| 263 | Tsuyoshi Wada, BAL | P | $1 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 262 | Casper Wells, SEA | OF | $1 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 261 | Ronny Paulino, BAL | C | $1 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 260 | Jake Arrieta, BAL | P | $1 | Patton & Co |
| 259 | Nick Punto, BOS | 2B | $1 | Baseball HQ |
| 258 | Vladimir Guerrero, BAL | DH | $1 | FanDuel.com |
| 257 | Ryan Lavarnway, BOS | C | $1 | Mastersball.com |
| 256 | Manny Ramirez, OAK | DH | $1 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 255 | Jason Marquis, MIN | P | $1 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 254 | Brett Anderson, OAK | P | $1 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 253 | Hank Conger, LAA | C | $1 | Patton & Co |
| 251 | Trayvon Robinson, SEA | OF | $1 | FanDuel.com |
| 250 | Vinnie Pestano, CLE | P | $1 | Mastersball.com |
| 249 | Hisashi Iwakuma, SEA | P | $1 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 248 | Jack Hannahan, CLE | 3B | $1 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 246 | Jonathan Broxton, KC | P | $1 | Patton & Co |
| 245 | Hisanori Takahashi, LAA | P | $1 | Baseball HQ |
| 243 | Matt LaPorta, CLE | 1B | $1 | Mastersball.com |
| 242 | Dallas Braden, OAK | P | $1 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 239 | Lou Marson, CLE | C | $1 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 238 | Tommy Milone, OAK | P | $1 | Fantasy Sports Empires.com |
| 237 | Derek Lowe, CLE | P | $1 | Patton & Co |
| 235 | Hector Noesi, SEA | P | $1 | FanDuel.com |
| 233 | Chris Parmelee, MIN | 1B | $1 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 231 | John Jaso, SEA | C | $1 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 226 | Jonny Gomes, OAK | OF | $1 | FanDuel.com |
| 222 | Andruw Jones, NYY | OF | $1 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
| 220 | Scott Downs, LAA | P | $1 | CBSSports.com (Melchior) |
| 205 | Freddy Garcia, NYY | P | $1 | Baseball HQ |
| 199 | Travis Hafner, CLE | DH | $1 | CBSSports.com (White) |
| 197 | Octavio Dotel, DET | P | $1 | Yahoo! Sports |
| 192 | Jason Hammel, BAL | P | $1 | Stats LLC |
| 186 | Kelly Shoppach, BOS | C | $1 | CBSSports.com (Eisenberg) |
