Forgot Log-in or  Password? |  Help  Not a member, Register Now!
Play Fantasy Use your Fantasy skills to win Cash Prizes. Join or start a league today. Play Now
      
Fantasy Football Today
2014 Draft Prep Guide
Gameday Inactives
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Get Your Draft Board
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Red Zone Stats
Teams
Schedules
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Playoff Challenge
Commissioner
Prize Leagues
Free
Office Pool Manager
Game Pick'em
Player Challenge
Fantasy Baseball Today
2014 Draft Prep Guide
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Rankings
Projections
Teams
Schedules
Probable Pitchers
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injuries
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Message Boards
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
Downloadable Draft Kit
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
No Fantasy Teams Found
 
 
 

2013 Draft Prep: Scott White's Busts

Senior Fantasy Writer
  •  

I don't want Carl Crawford on my Fantasy teams this year.

I don't want Curtis Granderson or Mark Teixeira either.

Of course, saying it now is different from saying it three weeks ago, when I first intended to say it. Now, with Granderson (broken forearm) and Teixeira (strained wrist) expected to miss at least a month with their respective injuries and Crawford's elbow showing it's still not completely whole after Tommy John surgery in August, those three are on just about everyone's bust lists.

Get your Custom Draft Kits!
Download your Draft Kit for Draft Day 2014 that's customized to your specific league scoring system, format and player pool!
Download your Draft Kit today!

And consequently, some people's sleeper lists.

So as much as I want to pile on the pessimism for those players, I feel like, to some degree, I'd be stating the obvious. And frankly, I'd rather use this space to open Fantasy owners' eyes to some possibilities they may not have considered before, even if it puts me at greater risk of being wrong.

That's not to say all of these choices are earth-shattering. Some you may have heard before. But obvious or not so obvious, all of them pass the money-where-my-mouth-is test in that I'm just not drafting them in my leagues.

And now, you'll know why.

Note: The numbers in parentheses reflect average draft position on CBSSports.com, assuming a 12-team league.

Starlin Castro, SS, Cubs (Roto: Rd. 3, H2H: Rd. 5)

So you like Castro, do you? Then answer me this: Why?

Because he's gotten better every year? OK, except his slugging percentage dipped last year, and his batting average and OPS were both career lows.

Because he steals bases? Yeah, he had 25 last year, but he was also caught 13 times. He won't keep getting the green light if he continues at that rate.

Because he's young and talented and, therefore, has to get better? Fine, but you could say the same thing about Ian Desmond, Asdrubal Cabrera, Elvis Andrus, Everth Cabrera, Andrelton Simmons, Jean Segura and a number of other shortstops that go much later in drafts.

Take a closer look at the numbers, and you'll see Castro has been the exactly the same -- and exactly what the scouts projected him to be -- in each of his three years in the big leagues: a potential 15-homer, 20-steal type who at his best can hit .300, but whose lack of plate discipline subjects him to fluctuations in batting average like he had last year, when he finished behind Derek Jeter in total points.

Are those contributions useful at shortstop? No doubt. But are they so rare that you should passing on Jason Heyward, Adam Jones and Allen Craig for him? I don't see it. In order to live up to his price tag, Castro has to take a step forward this year. Considering he has yet to do so in three years (and pretty much fulfilled his potential right of the gate), I'm not counting on it.

Gio Gonzalez, SP, Nationals (Roto: Rd. 5, H2H: Rd. 4)

Haven't we seen this story played out already? The wild lefty with a penchant for strikeouts finally quells the walks just enough to meet the potential everybody thought he had all along? You know, like Oliver Perez in 2004 or Jonathan Sanchez in 2010?

How'd that work out for them?

The difference for Gonzalez, of course, is that he was still a pretty good pitcher prior to last year, so maybe "bust" isn't the best label for him. But his walk rate of 3.4 per nine innings last year wasn't so great even if it was an improvement over the rest of his career. Wildness is still a part of his game, and if history holds, it's bound to make a comeback at some point.

Again, he was still pretty good as a 4.1-walks-per-nine innings guy in 2010 and 2011, pitching deep enough into games to record 15-plus victories and pile up plenty of strikeouts. But a rise in WHIP would make him basically Yovani Gallardo, who's a good 10 spots lower in the rankings.

Jacoby Ellsbury, OF, Red Sox (Roto: Rd. 4, H2H: Rd. 5)

As quickly as negativity typically builds for a player who happens to spend some time on the DL in back-to-back seasons or who shows even the faintest signs of regression, I can't for the life of me figure out why everyone is so forgiving of an outfielder who has missed 80-plus games two of the last three years and whose steals continue to decline at an alarming rate.

Maybe the steals thing is easy to overlook because the starting point for Ellsbury's decline was an astronomical 70 in 2009, but he hasn't had 40 in a season since then. And last year, in between injuries, he was on a 30-steal pace.

Who needs more than 30 steals from a power guy, you ask, presumably referring to the 32 home runs Ellsbury hit in 2011? So far, that's the only year in which he's hit even double-digit home runs, and his four in 303 at-bats last year don't suggest an encore is in store.

Plus, while nobody would call Ellsbury old at age 29, that's the same age Carl Crawford, a player with a similar skill set and similar propensity for injury, took a turn for the worse. Maybe it's an unfair comparison since Crawford ended up needing Tommy John surgery not long afterward, but the bottom line is the risk-to-reward ratio just doesn't add up for me with Ellsbury.

Roy Halladay, SP, Phillies (Roto: Rd. 6, H2H: Rd. 3)

Halladay's decline last year from Fantasy first-rounder to bench fodder was so swift and sudden that, if you're like me, you assumed there had to be more to it, and the sore shoulder that sidelined him for about two months midseason provided a convenient excuse.

"Oh, he was hurt. That's why his velocity dropped and, in turn, why his numbers suffered. He's still probably one of the best pitchers in the game, but just to be safe, let's bump him down a tier, putting him right there with James Shields and Johnny Cueto. Yeah, he might even be a value then. That'd be great."

Now, I'm beginning to think we didn't bump him down enough. In case you don't pay attention to such things, his spring line is awful, and his velocity has only gotten worse. Granted, spring struggles aren't out of the ordinary for established aces, but when the Phillies themselves are worried, having him tinker with his delivery under the watchful eye of pitching coach Rich Dubee, it's legitimate cause for concern. No little mechanical tweak is going to add 8 miles per hour to his fastball.

It doesn't mean you shouldn't draft Halladay. Even with last year's numbers, he was useful. Just understand that last year's numbers might not be so quickly forgotten.

Jason Kipnis, 2B, Indians (Roto: Rd. 6, H2H: Rd. 7)

Coming into draft season, I could have gone either way on Kipnis. At the right price, the upside certainly justifies the downside.

But unfortunately, he's getting drafted at a point that pretty much disregards the latter.

In order for it to pay off, he has to realize his best-case scenario. Paul Goldschmidt and Jose Altuve are kind of in the same boat, at least in Rotisserie leagues, but Kipnis is the one who scares me the most. Not only does he have to rebound from a putrid second half that saw him hit .233 with a .651 OPS, but he has to continue stealing bases at the rate he did last season, when he finished with 31.

Check out our Fantasy Baseball podcast!
Stay a step ahead of your competition in 2014 by checking out our popular Fantasy Baseball Today podcasts. Adam Aizer, Scott White and Al Melchior will entertain you and help you dominate all season.
Latest episode | Subscribe!

Nobody projected him as a 30-steals guy coming up through the minors. The most he had in a single season was 12. If he hits third for the Indians this year, his opportunities to run will naturally decrease -- and that's assuming his poor success rate in the second half last year, when he stole just 11 in 17 chances, doesn't artificially decrease them.

So basically, an unsustainably hot start last year inflated Kipnis' value to where it is now. Again, he has room to grow as a hitter, but based on how he finished last year, I wouldn't bank on him making the leap this year.

Mark Trumbo, 1B/OF, Angels (Roto: Rd. 7, H2H: Rd. 8)

Trumbo's back spasms in the second half last year serve as a nice little scapegoat for his .227 batting average and .630 OPS after the All-Star break. But judging from his skill set -- particularly the lack of plate discipline -- those numbers were as much a regression to the mean as anything else.

Trumbo's .306 batting average and .965 OPS in the first half were no doubt encouraging, but as a general rule, players who strike out more than every four at-bats don't offer much in the way of batting average. Yeah, there's Matt Kemp, but he's such an extraordinary talent that you can trust him to deliver an unreasonably high BABIP every year. Trumbo's .316 BABIP last year was in line with his minor-league BABIPs, and the result was a .268 batting average. He may have arrived at both numbers in a less-than-straightforward way, but judging from his minor-league track record, where he arrived is where he belonged.

So would a repeat of last year's numbers make him a bust? Based on where he's going, kind of. He ended up being only the 17th-ranked first baseman in Head-to-Head leagues last year. And as with any all-or-nothing slugger, there's always the potential for the batting average to collapse (see Mark Reynolds, Adam Dunn, Dan Uggla).

Mike Napoli, C/1B, Red Sox (Roto: Rd. 7, H2H: Rd. 9)

Prior to the 2011 season, when he looked like Mike Piazza with a .320 batting average, Napoli had hit .251 over his career. And of course, he hit .227 last year.

So which of those seasons -- 2011 or 2012 -- is the outlier? It shouldn't even be a question.

From what I can tell, two misconceptions are inflating Napoli's value now. One, some people are inclined to believe that the quad injury that limited him to 352 at-bats last year is also responsible for the low batting average. Maybe that explains why he didn't hit .260, but the decline from .320 has a much simpler explanation. Plus, it's not like his newly diagnosed hip condition is going to make him any more durable.

Two, some people assume that just because he's hit .306 with a 1.107 OPS at Fenway Park so far in his career, that's going to be his home split going forward. But it doesn't work that way. The sample, a full 62 at-bats, is too small. Theoretically, the Green Monster should complement Napoli's power stroke, but he was already playing at one of the most hitter-friendly parks in baseball. The move won't completely revolutionize him as a player.

Don't get me wrong: As a starting catcher, Napoli is fine in mixed leagues. But if I'm reaching for power at the position, I'm going with Wilin Rosario or Jesus Montero.

David Ortiz, DH, Red Sox (Roto: Rd. 8, H2H: Rd. 10)

In terms of Head-to-Head points per game, the top performers last year were Mike Trout, Ryan Braun, Miguel Cabrera and -- that's right -- Ortiz.

Bet you didn't know that. Oh really? Fine, then I bet most of your leaguemates don't, which is precisely why he seems to fit the mold of a sleeper.

But the reason I had to use points per game to assess him (as opposed to total points) is because he missed a large number of games last year -- the entire second half, basically -- with an Achilles injury. And he's having a hard time coming back from it at age 37, having yet to play this spring because of inflammation in both heels.

Which in and of itself is a reminder that 37 is practically ancient for a player whose athleticism has at times been called into question. Shoot, Ortiz looked like he was done for as a 33-year-old back in 2009. An improved approach against left-handers bought him a few more years, but this injury might be the nail in his coffin.

If an offseason of rest couldn't do the trick, I'm thinking it'll nag him off and on all season, costing him playing time and you the piece of mind you could have had with a top-30 starting pitcher at the same point in the draft.

Pablo Sandoval, 3B, Giants (Roto: Rd. 8, H2H: Rd. 9)

The Round Mound of Pound was a fitting nickname for Sandoval when he first broke into the big leagues, but lately, the emphasis has been more on the round than the pound.

At times, he's shown he can still be that .300-hitting, .900-OPS guy who took the league by storm in 2009. But for the most part, he didn't show it last year. And he certainly didn't in 2010.

Why not? Too often he's just too big for his own good. When he's over his ideal playing weight, everything seems to slow down: his bat, his reaction time in the field, his foot speed, etc. And, of course, he's at greater risk for some of the aches and pains that have so drastically limited his playing time the last couple years.

A strict dietary and workout regimen helped him get in shape for his resurgent 2011 season, but this spring, he showed up indisputably big.

So he's a performance risk, an injury risk and, potentially, a playing time risk. When you reach the point in your draft where Sandoval is the best you can do at third base, you might as well wait three or four rounds and draft David Freese instead.

Dan Haren, SP, Nationals (Roto: Rd. 12, H2H: Rd. 7)

I'll admit that at age 32, Dan Haren probably shouldn't be so evidently on the decline, but that doesn't mean we should ignore that he is. Last year, his back hurt, his velocity dropped, and his ERA ballooned -- all telltale signs of a decline. So why the free pass?

"Well, the back issue caused the dip in velocity, which contributed to the high ERA, so if he's saying he's healthy, he should be back to normal, right?"

OK, but who have you known with chronic back issues -- not a one-time injury, but lingering pains -- that, once they started, eventually went away? Don Mattingly? Todd Helton? Your Uncle Chuck? The poor guy ...

I don't doubt Haren's back will feel better at times, but if he was miraculously healed, he wouldn't be having so many velocity issues this spring. In a March 15 start against the Cardinals, he was topping out in the mid-80s. The highest he's been hitting this spring is 90. Based on those results, how can you have any hope of him averaging more on his fastball than the 88.5 miles per hour he did last year?

Apparently, some people manage. He's going ahead of breakout candidates Jordan Zimmermann and Jeff Samardzija, as well as the better-equipped-for-a-rebound Jon Lester.

Joel Hanrahan, RP, Red Sox (Roto: Rd. 13, H2H: Rd. 13)

If all was right for Hanrahan coming out of last season, his spring struggles wouldn't be such a big deal, but he's coming off a second-half performance in which his control disappeared on him.

It was especially apparent in September, when he issued 10 walks in nine innings. The result was a walk rate of 5.2 per nine innings for the season, almost triple his 2012 rate.

Hanrahan has had control problems in the past, so this latest bout, which seems to have carried over into spring training, probably isn't just a fluke. The pressure cooker of Boston likely won't do him any favors. If he gets off to a slow start, the fans and media will be calling for his head, and with Andrew Bailey, a former All-Star closer himself, and a rejuvenated Daniel Bard behind him, the Red Sox might feel compelled to oblige.

If you target Hanrahan over Sergio Romo, J.J. Putz, Greg Holland and Glen Perkins, as so many Fantasy owners do, you're taking an unnecessary risk.

Carlos Beltran, OF, Cardinals (Roto: Rd. 13, H2H: Rd. 13)

Beltran turns 36 at the end of April. He has a history of knee problems. He missed half of 2009, most of 2010 and about a two-week period of 2011 with injuries, and even in the second half of 2012, he battled hand, back and knee issues.

The only thing more miraculous than him ranking 14th among outfielders in Head-to-Head leagues last year is the fact he played 151 games.

It won't happen again. Too many factors are working against him. Even healthy 36-year-olds typically don't play more than five games a week, and Beltran, as we've just covered, is rarely healthy.

And this year when he goes down, the most likely candidate to fill in for him is uber prospect Oscar Taveras, who might be the best player to come through the Cardinals system since Albert Pujols. Considering Beltran slumped to a .236 batting average and .742 OPS in the second half last year, that switch, whenever it happens, could easily stick.

If you get Beltran at a discount, he's worth a roll of the dice, but at his going rate, you're better off passing on him for Michael Morse or Adam Eaton later.

Jonathan Broxton, RP, Reds (Roto: Rd. 16, H2H: Rd. 19)

Let's say Aroldis Chapman locks up the fifth starter role in spring training. Manager Dusty Baker, ever the friend to Fantasy owners, is doing his best to cast doubt on that front, but for the sake of argument, let's operate under that premise.

Broxton is still one of the riskier closers you could draft in Fantasy.

After continual meltdowns in back-to-back years with the Dodgers, he theoretically rebounded with the Royals and Reds last season, judging by his ERA and saves total. But look at the WHIP. Look at the hit rate. For that matter, look at a strikeout rate. Is a pitcher who averages 94.1 miles per hour on his fastball supposed to whiff just 7.0 batters per nine innings? Broxton's fastball is so straight and so flat that if it's not in the high 90s, like it was in his early Dodgers days, it's hittable.

And hittable is the last thing a closer can afford to be.

If Chapman thrives as a starter but Broxton falters as a closer, the Reds could easily turn to Sean Marshall, Jose Arredondo or perhaps even J.J. Hoover for ninth-inning duties. And if Chapman falters as a starter, well, what Broxton does won't even matter.

Stay in touch with the most passionate Fantasy staff in the business by following us on Twitter @CBSFantasyBB or Scott White at @CBSScottWhite . You can also e-mail us at fantasybaseball@cbsinteractive.com .

Get player news notifications, manage your team and check scores
- all updated in real time. Download the CBS Fantasy App.

  •  
 
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
COMMENTS
Conversation powered by Livefyre
 
 
Player News
Anibal Sanchez coming back Tuesday
by Scott White | Senior Fantasy Writer
(5:12 pm ET) The Tigers will activate right-hander Anibal Sanchez from the 15-day DL Tuesday, according to MLB.com. Sanchez, who has been out since Aug. 8 with a strained pectoral, threw a simulated game Sunday. 

Sanchez didn't have a chance to go on a minor-league rehab assignment because of the timing of his recovery, so he'll pitch out of the bullpen.


Ivan Nova hoping to return in May
by Scott White | Senior Fantasy Writer
(5:05 pm ET) Yankees starting pitcher Ivan Nova, who had Tommy John surgery in late April, hasn't had any setbacks so far and is aiming to return in May, manager Joe Girardi told the Wall Street Journal. He began a throwing program in late August.

Adam Eaton out due to personal matter
by Al Melchior | Data Analyst
(4:56 pm ET) CSNChicago.com reports that Adam Eaton has been away from the White Sox, as he has been dealing with a family matter. Eaton was away for Sunday's game at the Rays, and he is also out of the starting lineup for Monday's series opener at the Tigers. Moises Sierra is starting in center field in Eaton's absence.

It is not yet known when Eaton will return to the team.


Steve Pearce looking at Wednesday return
by Scott White | Senior Fantasy Writer
(4:55 pm ET) Orioles outfielder Steve Pearce was out of the lineup for a third straight game because of a sore wrist Monday at the Yankees, and according to MASNsports.com, he's not aiming to return until Wednesday.

Pearce, who received a cortisone shot in his wrist Saturday, was red hot before the injury, batting .405 (15 for 37) with four home runs in 11 games.


Brian Dozier to rest after heating up
by Al Melchior | Data Analyst
(4:44 pm ET) Twins manager Ron Gardenhire left Brian Dozier out of the starting lineup for Monday's game against the Diamondbacks. Doug Bernier got the start at second base in Dozier's place.

Dozier has a modest four-game hitting streak, but it represents his best stretch during an otherwise difficult month of September. He is 7 for 17 (.412) with a home run over the last four games, but prior to that, he was batting .136 for the month.


Chris Young out of rotation for now
by Scott White | Senior Fantasy Writer
(4:42 pm ET) Mariners starting pitcher Chris Young will not make his scheduled start Thursday at Toronto, according to MLB.com, though manager Lloyd McClendon didn't rule out him starting in the playoffs should the Mariners advance.

"I think he's probably out of gas from the starting standpoint," McClendon said. "Having said that, 8-10 days from now, who knows."

Though Young has been a key part of the Mariners' success this season, he has struggled in his last five starts, compiling an 8.35 ERA. His 165 innings this year are 50 more than he had last year and his most since he had 173 for the Padres in 2007. He will work out of the bullpen for now.


Joe Mauer to grab some pine
by Al Melchior | Data Analyst
(4:37 pm ET) Joe Mauer was left out of the Twins' starting lineup for Monday's game versus the Diamondbacks, as Chris Parmelee got the nod at first base. It is only the third time that Mauer has not started a game since he returned on Aug. 11 after spending time on the disabled list with a strained oblique.

Tyson Ross turns focus to 2015
by Scott White | Senior Fantasy Writer
(4:30 pm ET) Padres starting pitcher Tyson Ross, who missed his last start because of discomfort in his lower forearm, realizes he may have pitched for the last time this season, according to the San Diego Union-Tribune.

"I think the focus now is the long term, the 2015 season," he said. "I'd like to pitch, but I also need to get ready for next season and pitching deep into October."

Though Ross played catch Thursday and Friday, he hasn't exactly stayed in his routine since the injury, spending much of his time in the training room, which also diminishes his chances of returning this season.

"If he can amass the same number of innings or more next year, they're probably more important than the innings he might pitch the remainder of this week," manager Bud Black said.


Aaron Hicks returns from brief respite
by Al Melchior | Data Analyst
(4:28 pm ET) Aaron Hicks was in the Twins' starting lineup for Monday's game against the Diamondbacks. He missed the previous two games with a sore back.

Masahiro Tanaka gets good reviews
by Scott White | Senior Fantasy Writer
(4:21 pm ET) Yankees starting pitcher Masahiro Tanaka said he felt no pain in his right elbow after making his first start in more than three months Sunday against Toronto.

"Obviously, I'm very relieved," Tanaka said through a translator. "I don't exactly remember when, but gradually, as the game went on, I guess I stopped thinking about it."

Pitching coach Larry Rothschild was pleased as well, according to MLB.com.

"His warmups were really good. The sim games, the last one, the warmups were OK. Today there was a difference and you could see it right away in the force with which he threw the ball and the quickness to his arm, all of the things that you saw before he went on the DL. Warming up today, you could see it."

Tanaka will make another start Saturday at Boston to give the Yankees an even better indication if he can avoid surgery to repair the partially torn UCL in his right elbow.

"It's possible that he can get through this for quite a while. It's possible that it comes up and bites him, and that's it," Rothschild said. "We're hopeful that's it's the earlier scenario and that he's going to be fine and have a nice, long career with no problems."


 
 
 
Rankings