Forgot Log-in or  Password? |  Help  Not a member, Register Now!
Play Fantasy Use your Fantasy skills to win Cash Prizes. Join or start a league today. Play Now
      
Fantasy Football Today
2014 Draft Prep Guide
Gameday Inactives
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Get Your Draft Board
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Red Zone Stats
Teams
Schedules
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Playoff Challenge
Commissioner
Prize Leagues
Free
Office Pool Manager
Game Pick'em
Player Challenge
Fantasy Baseball Today
2014 Draft Prep Guide
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Rankings
Projections
Teams
Schedules
Probable Pitchers
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injuries
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Message Boards
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
Downloadable Draft Kit
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
No Fantasy Teams Found
 
 
 

Reality Check: There's a catch at catcher

Senior Fantasy Writer
  •  

They're two of the most added players at one of the weakest positions in Fantasy. They're homering in bunches, playing critical roles for teams that initially viewed them as no more than placeholders.

And yet they're still destined to lose their jobs later this year.

John Buck and Evan Gattis. They're alike in more than just their beardedness. And yet they require distinct approaches in Fantasy because of one key difference:

One has a long history of nothing. The other has a brief history of ... well, something.

Which sounds more appealing to you?

Oh, well, that's not entirely fair to Buck, is it? He had that All-Star appearance in 2010 with the Blue Jays, when he set career highs with a .281 batting average and 20 home runs. That's something, isn't it?

Sure, but he followed it with two nothing seasons for the Marlins in which he hit a combined .213. And for that little something he did in 2010, he still produced a .314 on-base percentage. Only 28 qualifying batters had a lower mark than that.

And only two of them were catchers.

So during his one "great" year, Buck was really just average. And what about this year? Even with everything he's done right so far, his on-base percentage is still only .318.

Oh, you Moneyball types kill me with your on-base nonsense. Baseball is a big game of Battleship. Hit or miss. That's all that matters. Batting average makes the world go 'round, and anyone who says otherwise can walk over here and see if I hit or miss.

About that. Apart from 2010, Buck's highest batting average for a single season is .247, and he entered this season with a career .235 mark. Yeah, he has some pop, but between the low contact rate and minimal walks, he's the definition of all or nothing.

Most Added Players (as of 4/16)
Player % change
1. Evan Gattis, C, Braves 63
2. Tony Cingrani, SP, Reds 51
3. John Buck, C, Mets 38
4. Jake Westbrook, SP, Cardinals 38
5. Barry Zito, SP, Giants 35
6. Chris Carter, OF, Astros 30
7. Brandon Crawford, SS, Giants 30
8. Brandon Moss, 1B, Athletics 28
9. Matt Adams, 1B, Cardinals 25
10. Andrew Bailey, RP, Red Sox 24

And too often, the nothing takes precedence.

Oh, pish posh. Didn't you see The Lion King? The past is the past. Learn from it or get hit by a stick. You remember A.J. Pierzynski? Carlos Ruiz? It's happening again, and it's mine this time! I know it! I've always known it! You won't trick me into dropping him, Scott White! You lose, suckers!

Ah yes, Pierzynski and Ruiz, two catchers who, at a stage when their best should already be well behind him, eschewed all historical data with career-best numbers. And they both did it last year, rendering all Fantasy writers' cries of track record, sample size and regression to the mean nothing more than white noise.

White noise? That's everything you write!

Oh, thank you, Statler. Give my regards to Waldorf, will you?

But come on. Just because you can identify an aberration or two doesn't mean it's the new basis for comparison. Think of all the players whose hot starts went on to mean absolutely nothing.

Having trouble? Well, that's kind of the point.

In 2004, Hee-Seop Choi hit nine home runs in his first 21 games. He would hit 21 more in his career. In 2005, Brian Roberts hit six home runs in his first 14 games. We all know him as a power hitter today, right? In 2006, Craig Wilson hit six home runs in his first 13 games. He finished that season as a bench player for the Yankees. Also in 2006, Jonny Gomes hit 10 home runs in his first 20 games. It wound up being half his total in a year he hit a Buck-like .216. In 2008, Casey Kotchman hit six home runs in his first 20 games. Yes, the same Casey Kotchman whose career high in homers is 14. That actually happened. In 2010, Jose Guillen hit seven home runs in his first 18 games. He hit .242 the rest of the way and hasn't played in the majors since.

Just last year, light-hitting, contact specialist Omar Infante hit five home runs in his first 13 games. Remember that? Probably not. It turned out to be completely irrelevant

The bottom line with these early-season overachievers, particularly ones with track records as extensive as Buck's, is that, outside of natural progression for a player in his mid-20s or some mechanical adjustment for a player who has long fallen short of his pedigree, they almost always revert to their usual selves.

Take Alex Gonzalez. His career batting average and OPS are about on par with Buck's, and he has demonstrated similar home run potential throughout his career. If he hit six home runs in his first 11 games, like Buck has this year, where would you expect him to go from there?

Check out our Fantasy Baseball podcast!
Stay a step ahead of your competition in 2014 by checking out our popular Fantasy Baseball Today podcasts. Adam Aizer, Scott White and Al Melchior will entertain you and help you dominate all season.
Latest episode | Subscribe!

Well, he did hit four home runs in his first six games back in 2010 and had seven to go along with a .946 OPS by the end of April. But he proved to be exactly who we knew him to be the rest of the way, hitting .243 with a .701 OPS.

Look, if you came into this season planning to use catcher as sort of a vagrant position, continually swapping out your starter for the hot hand off the waiver wire, then yes, Buck certainly qualifies as the hot hand.

But if you have any hopes of landing a fixture at the position, you should look elsewhere, perhaps digging as deep as Tyler Flowers or Jason Castro or preemptively stashing a next-in-line type like Travis d'Arnaud or Mike Zunino. And certainly, if you still have a shot at Gattis, who remains unowned in more leagues than Buck, you have to make the switch.

Oh yeah, Gattis. Talk about fool's gold. The guy's 26, and he's just now reaching the big leagues? Hey, I've got another hot pickup for you: Mike Hessman. Or how about Crash Davis? Yeah, that's a good one.

OK, so maybe Gattis didn't appear on all the top prospects lists prior to this season, but only because he didn't have enough time to make an impression. He was a top recruit coming out of high school but battled addiction and depression soon afterward, going four years without playing baseball.

Once he got a chance to play in the Braves' minor-league system, he showed he hadn't lost his touch, beating up on lower-level pitching before proving himself at Double-A Mississippi late last year.

He's patient at the plate and makes hard contact when he does swing, hitting screaming line drives all over the field. And as for his power potential, one look at him tells the story there. I'm talking forearms the size of my neck.

Well, what about Brian McCann? A six-time All-Star getting displaced by some flavor of the week? That's rich.

But it's not so far-fetched given the way the Braves have already come to value Gattis' bat. In a lineup loaded with power hitters, he's the one batting cleanup with Freddie Freeman out, and while reigning NL MVP Buster Posey, another catcher, has to sit every fifth day for the Giants, Gattis gets to play other positions on his "off" days just so manager Fredi Gonzalez can keep his bat in the lineup.

Already this year, the Braves have used Gattis at first base. In the minors last year, he played mostly left field. It's not like he's a catcher, and so when McCann comes back, that's it. He's a slugger who happens to play some catcher, among other things.

And no, that's not a subtle jab at his defense.

Obviously, McCann will get his at-bats when he returns two or three weeks from now. He's a six-time All-Star, a leader and all of that. But he's also coming off shoulder surgery after a career-worst season and, as an impedning free agent, most likely isn't in the team's long-term plans.

Translation: Full-time at-bats probably aren't in his future.

Here's how I see it going down: McCann gets most of the starts at catcher, perhaps four a week, but Gattis gets more starts overall. The Braves have equipped him with the versatility to make it possible. Plus, all three of their starting outfielders are capable of playing all three outfield positions, so Gattis can fill in for any of them at any time.

Let's say one week he gets two starts at catcher, a spot start for Freeman and a spot start for B.J. Upton. Great, that's four starts. Let's say the next week he gets two starts at catcher, a spot start for Jason Heyward and a spot start for Justin Upton. Great, that's another four starts.

It's less than perfect, sure, but catchers don't play every day anyway. Four starts per week, for a player with Gattis' offensive ability, is potentially enough to make him a top-12 option at the position.

And of course, if Heyward or one of the Upton brothers gets hurt, as they've been known to do, he's back to playing full-time.

You know who might not be able to survive a playing time crunch? Buck. That d'Arnaud guy I mentioned earlier, the one who was ready to break into the majors before tearing a knee ligament last July, he's knocking on the door at Triple-A Las Vegas, and if Buck hits .180 over the next three weeks, as he's apt to do, the prize of the R.A. Dickey deal is likely to break it down.

And once he does, Buck might have to go the Craig Wilson route to get halfway consistent at-bats.

Stay in touch with the most passionate Fantasy staff in the business by following us on Twitter @CBSFantasyBB or Scott White at @CBSScottWhite . You can also e-mail us at fantasybaseball@cbsinteractive.com .

Get player news notifications, manage your team and check scores
- all updated in real time. Download the CBS Fantasy App.

  •  
 
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
COMMENTS
Conversation powered by Livefyre
 
 
Player News
Welington Castillo out of lineup Saturday
by R.J. White | CBSSports.com
(10:09 am ET) Cubs catcher Welington Castillo is not in the starting lineup for Saturday's game against the Dodgers.

Castillo left Friday's game in the first inning with a rib injury. He has hit .238/.299/.382 with 11 home runs and 42 RBI in 361 at-bats.


Indians optimistic Jason Kipnis returns this weekend
by R.J. White | CBSSports.com
(10:04 am ET) Indians manager Terry Francona is optimistic that second baseman Jason Kipnis will return to action this weekend, MLB.com reports.

Kipnis is day-to-day with a hamstring injury after exiting Thursday's game. However, he felt much better by the time he got to the ballpark Friday. "He showed up and actually exhibited pretty good strength," Francona said Friday before the game. "He's sore enough where we're not going to play him today. We would see about tomorrow, but I think we're more in that range, as opposed to four or five days. I think when you say 'day to day,' we really are legitimately day to day."


Mike Zunino knocks 21st home run Friday
by R.J. White | CBSSports.com
(9:58 am ET) Mariners catcher Mike Zunino went 2 for 5 with a three-run home run in his team's 10-5 win over the Astros Friday.

Zunino broke a 1-1 tie with his fourth-inning blast, putting his team up for good and earning a critical win as the Mariners chase a potential Wild Card berth. Despite displaying quality power numbers this season, Zunino has struggled to consistently deliver hits. He owns a .199/.256/.409 line with 21 home runs and 57 RBI in 413 at-bats.


Alex Avila still out of lineup Saturday
by R.J. White | CBSSports.com
(9:55 am ET) Tigers catcher Alex Avila remains out of the starting lineup for Saturday's game against the Royals.

Avila reportedly felt "disoriented" after taking some swings in the batting cages recently, and his post-concussion symptoms may end up keeping him sidelined for the rest of the regular season. The Tigers are concerned about the catcher, ESPN reports.


Kennys Vargas blasts ninth home run Friday
by R.J. White | CBSSports.com
(9:51 am ET) Twins desginated hitter Kennys Vargas went 2 for 5 with a solo home run in his team's 5-4 win over the Indians Friday.

Vargas has homered twice in his last three games while delivering six hits in 14 at-bats. On the negative side, he added three strikeouts to his two hits Friday. Vargas owns a .295/.310/.495 with nine home runs and 37 RBI in 190 at-bats.


Oswaldo Arcia swats 19th home run Friday
by R.J. White | CBSSports.com
(9:49 am ET) Twins outfielder Oswaldo Arcia excelled in his return to action Friday, going 3 for 4 with a home run and two RBI in his team's 5-4, 10-inning victory over the Indians.

Arcia put the first run of the game on the board in the third inning, slugging a solo home run to right field. He then added an RBI single in the seventh inning to bring his team within one before the Twins plated a runner in the ninth and another in the 10th to pick up a walkoff win. Arcia has hit .237/.308/.469 with 19 home runs and 54 RBI in 337 at-bats.


Michael Brantley slugs 20th home run Friday
by R.J. White | CBSSports.com
(9:45 am ET) Indians outfielder Michael Brantley went 2 for 5 with a solo home run in his team's 5-4 loss to the Twins Friday.

Brantley also added a double while extending his hitting streak to 10 games. He's also collected at least one hit in 22 of his last 23 games. Setting career highs virtually across the board in 2014, Brantley has delivered his first 20-20 campaign this year, hitting .322/.380/.502 with 20 home runs, 95 RBI and 22 stolen bases in 584 at-bats.


Logan Forsythe slugs sixth home run Friday
by R.J. White | CBSSports.com
(9:41 am ET) Rays second baseman Logan Forsythe went 2 for 3 with a double, a home run and three RBI in his team's 4-3 defeat against the White Sox.

Forsythe hadn't collected an extra-base hit since homering on Aug. 14, but he was swung a hot bat Friday, driving in two runs with a first-inning double before smacking a solo home run in the fourth inning to put his team up 3-0. Unfortunately, that was all the offense they'd find, leading to a loss after the White Sox scored four times in the fifth inning. Forsythe has hit .231/.296/.343 with six home runs, 26 RBI and two stolen bases in 286 at-bats.


Daniel Murphy racks up four hits in win Friday
by R.J. White | CBSSports.com
(9:37 am ET) Mets second baseman Daniel Murphy went 4 for 5 and scored a run in his team's 5-0 win over the Braves Friday.

Murphy has been filling in at third base for David Wright, making eight starts at the position in the last 10 days. He has hit .299/.341/.416 with nine home runs, 54 RBI and 13 stolen bases in 565 at-bats.


Rafael Ynoa drives in three runs in four-hit night Friday
by R.J. White | CBSSports.com
(9:33 am ET) Rockies third baseman Rafael Ynoa went 4 for 5 with two doubles, one triple and three RBI in his team's 15-3 win over the Diamondbacks Friday.

Ynoa has done well since being brought up at the beginning of September, entering the game 11 for 31 in 10 appearances. However, all 11 of his previous hits had been singles before he came through with three extra-base hits Friday. He has now hit .417/.417/.528 in 35 at-bats.


 
 
 
Rankings