Forgot Log-in or  Password? |  Help  Not a member, Register Now!
Play Fantasy Use your Fantasy skills to win Cash Prizes. Join or start a league today. Play Now
      
Fantasy Football Today
2014 Draft Prep Guide
Gameday Inactives
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Get Your Draft Board
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Red Zone Stats
Teams
Schedules
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Playoff Challenge
Commissioner
Prize Leagues
Free
Office Pool Manager
Game Pick'em
Player Challenge
Fantasy Baseball Today
2014 Draft Prep Guide
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Rankings
Projections
Teams
Schedules
Probable Pitchers
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injuries
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Message Boards
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
Downloadable Draft Kit
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
No Fantasy Teams Found
 
 
 

Reality Check: The price for Puig

Senior Fantasy Writer
  •  

Would you trade Yasiel Puig for Matt Kemp?

Among the many hypotheticals thrown our way during a typical Fantasy Baseball Today (weekdays, LIVE @ noon ET) episode, this one seemed innocuous enough, yet when presented with it on Monday's show, I hesitated and recognized how drastically it could alter a Fantasy owner's fate.

On the surface, yes, trading Puig, who I have 43rd among outfielders in my rest-of-season rankings, for Kemp, who I have 20th, seems automatic. But I say that as someone on the outside looking in, as one who won't have to live with the consequences of Kemp never rediscovering his stroke or of Puig continuing to terrorize the league.

Is either of those scenarios the most likely one for that player? My guess is no, which is why I rank Puig and Kemp the way I do, but neither is the kind of predication I can make with 99 percent assurance. It's more like 60-40.

Which brings me to the broader question concerning Puig: Now what?

Let's say you have him. I'll get to if you don't in a minute, but for now, he's yours. You beat everyone else to him and have relished every moment since. The easy response would be to just plug him into your lineup and let him do his thing.

But would that be for the best?

Since your mad dash to the waiver wire, Puig's value has escalated. He's gotten off to an impossibly hot start, becoming just the second player since 1900 to hit four home runs in his first five games as a pro. But the numbers don't tell the whole story. The timing of his feats -- from the game-tying three-run homer June 4 to the grand slam that cushioned the Dodgers' one-run lead Thursday to the game-tying solo shot just one day later, not to mention all the game-changing, highlight-reel assists from right field -- has elevated him to almost mythical status.

In short, you aren't the only one relishing every moment. Everyone else sees what's going on with Puig and can't help but think, "Man, I wish ..."

Which is, of course, the perfect recipe for a sell-high candidate.

Now, here's where it get tricky: What if Puig really is this good -- or, perhaps more applicable, what if he's really this good this soon?

I wouldn't even entertain the possibility if not for Mike Trout last year. Before him, the assumption for any rookie who took the league by storm in his first few weeks on the job was that he'd inevitably meet with an adjustment period that would bring his numbers down to size. He may overcome it soon enough to finish the year among the best at his position, but he'd bring a certain level of frustration to those who owned him in Fantasy -- and without any real assurances.

Yes, before Trout, rookies who could not only help a Fantasy team, but carry it, came along once every generation, like Albert Pujols.

Most Added Players (as of 6/11)
Player Name % change
1. Gerrit Cole, SP, Pirates 46
2. Kyle Blanks, OF, Padres 31
3. Tony Cingrani, SP, Reds 30
4. Anthony Rendon, 2B, Nationals 27
5. Carlos Quentin, OF, Padres 26
6. Adam Lind, 1B, Blue Jays 22
7. Bartolo Colon, SP, Athletics 18
8. Jose Iglesias, SS, Red Sox 17
9. Ryan Doumit, C, Twins 16
10. Jason Marquis, SP, Padres 16

So maybe Trout just so happens to be this generation's Pujols -- i.e., a beautiful, freakish aberration. It stands to reason. But Puig is doing his best to suggest otherwise. Unlike Trout, who struggled to the tune of a .220 batting average in his first taste of the majors back in 2011, Puig has only thrived against major-league pitching so far, carrying his .517 batting average and 1.328 OPS from spring training into his first week as a pro. And unlike most rookies, he most likely already has some experience against upper-level competition from his playing days in Cuba.

Why couldn't he be that rare case of lightning striking twice, living up to all the Bo Jackson comparisons by delivering the kind of numbers that shake up the standings? It's a relative long shot, judging by all the rookies who've come before him, but for some Fantasy owners, that long shot is all they have.

At 4-6 or 3-7, they're close to dropping out of the playoff picture and on the verge of not even caring anymore. They don't need just another good player to get them back in the race. The need a miracle of Mike Trout proportions. And now, with Puig, they have hope.

Unless someone in their league is so enamored with Puig's potential that he's willing to give up a stud hitter like Edwin Encarnacion or Adrian Beltre or a true ace like Justin Verlander or (as one person on Twitter suggested might actually be a possibility) Adam Wainwright, they're not going to find that same hope on the trade market.

So while in a vacuum, trading Puig for someone more assured like Alex Rios, Ian Desmond or Billy Butler makes almost too much sense, in certain situations, it's the equivalent of looking a gift horse in the mouth.

The same would apply if you don't own Puig but have a chance to trade for him. I had such a chance with a similarly unproven Trout in the Podcast Listeners' League at this time last year when host/producer Adam Aizer, owner of the first-place team, marketed him for pitching.

Off to a miserable start at 3-7, I offered Matt Moore, who wasn't quite as established as he is now. In terms of risk-reward, he was something like this year's R.A. Dickey -- a pitcher whose big potential is shrouded in inconsistency. (It's not the cleanest comparison, but you get the idea.) Adam accepted.

I didn't know if Trout was the answer at the time, but I had a pretty a good idea Moore wasn't. I needed a miracle, so instead of clinging to my occasional ace just because he was one of the few commodities I had, I decided to put my faith in the 20-year-old wunderkind who, as little as he offered in the way of track record, at least came with the assurance that someday he's supposed to be good.

Sound familiar?

Of course, by then it was too late. In a league where only four teams advanced to the playoffs, I had dug myself into a deeper hole than even Trout could pull me out of. But at least I made a game out of it. With Trout, my team was immeasurably better.

And Adam? Well, he can't complain too much. He went on to win the league -- with some help from Moore, of course. That's not to say he wouldn't have won if he had held on to Trout, but because he accomplished his ultimate objective, I doubt he regrets the move.

Which says something about the way the other half should treat Puig.

Teams already in good shape shouldn't have to resort to miracles to claim the title. If you buy into the idea that Puig is more likely to emerge as an above-average-to-good mixed-league outfielder than a one-man wrecking crew as a rookie, then why take the chance of him being anything less? Instead, take this opportunity, while his value has peaked, to pawn him off to someone else in search of a miracle, getting back something far better than you could ever hope to find on waivers, like a Rios, Desmond or Butler.

Check out our Fantasy Baseball podcast!
Stay a step ahead of your competition in 2014 by checking out our popular Fantasy Baseball Today podcasts. Adam Aizer, Scott White and Al Melchior will entertain you and help you dominate all season.
Latest episode | Subscribe!

What happens after then is inconsequential. If Puig continues to Hulk out on the rest of the league and the other guy ends up "winning" the deal, who cares? You probably locked up the title by making the trade, and keeping Puig wouldn't have accomplished more than that. It only would have exposed you to more risk.

It's sort of like a retirement plan. The closer you get to the goal, the less risk you want to take.

Puig is risk -- risk of regression, with risk of demotion attached to that regression. Because of that, he's more valuable to the teams with the least to lose and the most to gain.

What about those in between -- the owners of the 5-5 and 6-4 teams? Whether you're a seller or buyer of Puig ultimately comes down to the direction you think your team is headed, the alternatives you already have and, of course, what you'd be getting or giving in return. Risk or no risk, nobody's suggesting you dump Puig. Even the owner of an 8-2 team is looking to sell high on him, settling for nothing less than a player he can expect to start every week. Likewise, nobody's suggesting you offer up a Carlos Gonzalez or Prince Fielder for Puig, requiring him to meet the full extent of his potential just to recoup your losses.

Naturally, asking too little or giving too much for Puig isn't the answer, so if you're not comfortable with the direction your negotiations take, your best bet is to sit on him and wait.

Which brings us back to Kemp. He presents a high degree of risk himself, so I'm not sure I'd ever be comfortable acquiring him in a deal. I suppose I have more faith in him meeting his best-case scenario than Puig, but unless I was already running away with the league, I think I'd have more to lose than gain by pulling the trigger on this deal now.

Two weeks from now, we'll only have a better idea of Puig's true value, and two weeks from now, Kemp might still be hurt.

Stay in touch with the most passionate Fantasy staff in the business by following us on Twitter @CBSFantasyBB or Scott White at @CBSScottWhite . You can also e-mail us at fantasybaseball@cbsinteractive.com .

Get player news notifications, manage your team and check scores
- all updated in real time. Download the CBS Fantasy App.

  •  
 
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
COMMENTS
Conversation powered by Livefyre
 
 
Player News
Santiago Casilla gets the win in two-inning outing
by Al Melchior | Data Analyst
(10:40 am ET) Giants manager Bruce Bochy called upon Santiago Casilla in Monday's extra-inning affair against the Dodgers, and he held the opponent scoreless for the 11th and 12th innings. That kept the Giants alive, making their three-run 13th inning and 5-2 victory possible.

Casilla was credited with the win, as he faced the minimum six batters. Yasiel Puig reached base on a Brandon Crawford throwing error, and Darwin Barney got on after Casilla hit him, but double play balls erased both batters.

Now 3-3 on the season, Casilla lowered his ERA to 1.76.


Jake Peavy settles for no-decision
by Igor Mello | CBSSports.com
(1:25 am ET) Giants pitcher Jake Peavy wasn't a factor into the decision Monday night in Los Angeles against the Dodgers. He allowed two runs on four hits and one walk while striking out four over seven innings of work.

Over his last six starts covering 41 innings, Peavy has allowed only five earned runs. He owns a 3.78 ERA and a 1.27 WHIP over 31 starts (197 2/3 innings). His final start of the regular season will come at home Saturday against San Diego.


Dan Haren fans seven in no-deicison
by Igor Mello | CBSSports.com
(1:25 am ET) Dodgers pitcher Dan Haren struck out seven but wasn't a factor into the decision Monday night at home against the Giants. He allowed two runs -- one earned -- on one hit and no walks over seven innings of work. Of his 100 pitches, 65 were strikes.

Over his last five starts covering 31 innings, Haren has allowed seven earned runs. He owns a 4.03 ERA and a 1.18 WHIP over 31 starts (181 innings). His final start of the regular season will come Saturday at home against Colorado.


C.J. Wilson gets the quick hook vs. Oakland
by Igor Mello | CBSSports.com
(1:25 am ET) Angels pitcher C.J. Wilson was yanked in the opening frame after a brief but abysmal outing Monday night against the A's, dropping to 13-10 on the year. He was shelled for six runs -- four earned -- on two hits and four walks over two-thirds of an inning.

Wilson owns a 4.61 ERA and a 1.46 WHIP over 30 starts (169 2/3 innings). He will try to end the regular season on a positive note on Sunday in Seattle.


Jeff Samardzija twirls a gem in win over Angels
by Igor Mello | CBSSports.com
(1:25 am ET) Athletics pitcher Jeff Samardzija turned in a gem Monday night at home against the Angels, improving to 7-12 on the year. He allowed one unearned run on five hits and no walks while striking out three over seven innings of an 8-4 victory.

Samardzija has not permitted a run over his last two starts (15 innings). He owns a 2.88 ERA and a 1.06 WHIP over 32 starts (212 2/3 innings). His final start of the regular season will come Saturday at Texas.


Tyler Matzek pegged with tough-luck loss
by Igor Mello | CBSSports.com
(1:07 am ET) Rockies pitcher Tyler Matzek was pegged with a tough-luck loss Monday night in San Diego, dropping to 6-11 on the year. He allowed one run on four hits and three walks while striking out eight over six innings of work.

Over his last five starts covering 33 2/3 innings, Matzek has allowed five earned runs. His season comes to an end with a 4.05 ERA and a 1.39 WHIP over 117 2/3 innings of work. He struck out 91 and walked 44 over that span.


Eric Stults keeps Rockies in check Monday
by Igor Mello | CBSSports.com
(1:02 am ET) Padres pitcher Eric Stults dominated the Rockies at home on Monday, scattering seven hits and 6 1/3 scoreless innings to improve to 8-17 on the year. He struck out five and walked one. Of his 93 pitches, 66 were strikes.

Stults owns a 4.42 ERA and a 1.40 WHIP over 31 starts (169 innings). He will make his final start of the season Saturday in San Francisco.


Kevin Quackenbush collects sixth save
by Igor Mello | CBSSports.com
(1:02 am ET) Padres closer Kevin Quackenbush converted his sixth save of the season Monday night at home against the Rockies. He struck out one and allowed one hit in a scoreless ninth inning of work for the save. He needed 19 pitches to close out a 1-0 victory. He has converted 6 of 7 save chances, with a 2.58 ERA and a 1.09 WHIP over 52 1/3 innings of relief.

Aaron Hill suffers dislocated pinkie finger
by Igor Mello | CBSSports.com
(12:37 am ET) Diamondbacks second baseman Aaron Hill suffered a dislocated right pinkie finger Monday night against the Twins, according to MLB.com. Hill sustained the injury while sliding into home plate in the eighth inning and was not taken out of the game.

Hill is hitting .244/.287/.367 with 10 homers and 60 RBI over 501 at-bats. His status remains uncertain for Tuesday's game against the Twins.


Jason Hammel scheduled to return Thursday against Texas
by Igor Mello | CBSSports.com
(12:33 am ET) Athletics pitcher Jason Hammel will return to the starting rotation on Thursday against the Rangers, MLB.com reports. Hammel missed his previous turn to attend the birth of his child. He owns a 3.54 ERA and a 1.13 WHIP over 170 1/3 innings of work.

 
 
 
Rankings