Forgot Log-in or  Password? |  Help  Not a member, Register Now!
      
Fantasy Football Today
Fantasy Football Today Blog
Gameday Inactives
2014 Draft Prep Guide
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Get Your Draft Board
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Schedules
Scores
Fantasy Games
Playoff Challenge
Commissioner
Prize Leagues
Free
Office Pool Manager
Game Pick'em
Player Challenge
Fantasy Baseball Today
Fantasy Baseball Today Blog
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Rankings
Projections
Schedules
Probable Pitchers
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injuries
Projections
Rankings
Schedules
Message Boards
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
Downloadable Draft Kit
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
No Fantasy Teams Found
 
 
 

Disclaimed interest by NBPA? Here's what it means to labor squabble

Matt Moore
CBSSports.com Senior NBA Blogger
  •  

Meet the new faces of the NBA players' labor fight -- David Boies (left) and Jeffrey Kessler. (Getty Images)  
Meet the new faces of the NBA players' labor fight -- David Boies (left) and Jeffrey Kessler. (Getty Images)  

So the NBPA decided to circumvent any more playing footsy with the NBA and just decertified. Only they didn't decertify. They "disclaimed interest." Here's what that actually means.

What's the difference between decertification and a disclaimer of interest?

Collective bargaining was established to protect employers in their negotiations with unions and vice-versa. Subsequently, it was established in U.S. law that employers are exempt from antitrust litigation, provided they stay within the framework of collective bargaining. So if you want to sue your employer for antitrust, you need to dissolve your union.

You can do that two ways. You can decertify, which involves what we've been talking about, where union membership petitions for a vote to decertify the union; the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) verifies that petition; and then a vote is held to decertify, needing a simple majority to pass. Or you can disclaim interest -- which means union leadership dissolves itself. Decertification is bottom-up; disclaimer of interest is top-down.

So which is better, disclaimer of interest or decertification?

There are advantages and drawbacks to both. Decertification takes longer, which is the primary reason the NBPA elected to go the other route. A disclaimer of interest essentially goes into effect immediately upon paperwork being filed with the U.S. Department of Labor. The National Basketball Trade Association's new lawyers told reporters Monday that should they elect to file suit against the NBA (which they will), they won't be seeking an injunction, but a summary judgment.

More on NBA lockout
Analysis

Stories

Disclaim of interest brings with it a greater threat the court will rule it a "sham" negotiating tactic, but to counter that the agents behind the recent decertification movement will submit their petitions for an involuntary decertification as counter-evidence. Disclaim of interest also removes the NLRB from interest in the case -- without a union, the NLRB has no jurisdiction. In short, disclaimer of interest is faster, but doesn't carry the weight decertification does.

Can the players and league still negotiate?

In the interim, between the disclaimer and the suit being considered, negotiations can take place ... but not with the players as a whole. They no longer exist as a collective entity. Teams can negotiate only with individual players. And of course the teams won't, since they consider this to be a "sham" dissolution meant only as a negotiating tactic. Also, the NBA would lose its protection from antitrust laws if it negotiated with individual players instead of a union.

The only way a new CBA is ratified is if the threat of legal action -- or a summary judgment with substantial damages -- forces the league to abandon its position and cave to the players.

I'll let you determine the odds of that based on your working knowledge of, you know, logic. But if you want the legal perspective, based on the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals' ruling in the NFL case as well as antitrust standards, David Scupp, an antitrust litigation expert, says that while the players may not have a lot to lose in this pursuit based on where the CBA negotiations were, "their prospects are not great."

Why didn't the players decertify?

Because it takes longer. But the other thing to consider is that an involuntary decertification provides protection from the "sham" argument. A movement from within the players against union leadership to dissolve the union is pretty unlikely to be determined to be a sham. In contrast, the disclaimer of interest is more succeptible to that, although the players have have substantial evidence that disclaiming was their only option after the league negotiator repeatedly issued ultimatums and informed them that negotiations were over unless the players accepted their offer. That's one of the many questions to be answered.

What happens next?

If we assume the players are going to file suit -- which is what's going to happen, that's why you do this -- then the first question is where the case will be heard. The players will want California, the 9th Circuit, which is more favorable toward unions. The league will push for the same court they filed suit in, the 2nd Circuit in New York, which has been their friend in the past. From there, the players will ask for a summary judgment. The court proceedings regarding the actual suit cannot begin until the issue of where the case will be heard is settled, a process that takes more time off the season's clock.

A summary judgment? Not to get too technical on you, but it's basically looking for the court to say, "Obviously! Of course the NBA is wrong! Here you go!" It seeks to circumvent a trial in cases with no disputes of "material fact." Scupp told CBSSports.com that a summary judgment is granted when the court rules there are "no issues of fact" and that a trial is not needed. In short, the players want to get around the wait of a trial and gain a decision in their favor as quickly as possible. There still have to be motions, exhibits, discovery, etc., so a summary judgment could take longer than an injunction -- but it potentially has more value. The NFL players got an injunction lifting the lockout in their antitrust case against the NFL, but it was lifted in a matter of days while the 8th Circuit considered the appeal.

Scupp says the players could file for the summary judgment specifically on the grounds that the NBA's lockout is illegal. In that scenario, if granted, the players could earn triple their lost salary in damages -- as opposed to an injunction, which would simply lift the lockout and force the players to resume play. Ken Berger of CBSSports.com reports that if the summary judgment was granted in 60 days, which is the soonest it could be (and even that is a stretch), the league could face damages as high as $2.4 billion. As the 8th Circuit ruled that the court could not enjoin such a lockout, the players are looking to dodge that question and instead focus on the fact that the court did not rule on whether the lockout was in fact legal.

In any instance, Scupp says it's likely the NBA would file a counter-motion for its own summary judgment. Such a ruling would block any further efforts by the players outside of appeal on the grounds of the lockout being illegal. The NBA also would appeal a possible summary judgment against it, but the impact of having a potentially multi-billion-dollar judgment against the owners might be enough to prompt them to settle.

Also, there are expected to be at least two lawsuits -- a class-action suit challenging every aspect of the NBA business, such as the salary cap, luxury tax and draft as antitrust violations, and another one specifically on behalf of rookies and free agents.

Why the second one? In the majority opinion in the NFL case, the 8th Circuit panel specifically questioned whether employees who are not under contract can be locked out. It could be on behalf of such rookies and free agents that the players would be able to achieve their quickest and most decisive legal opinion rejecting the NBA's operations as illegal.

From there, we start to answer the question of whether the players have a case here, and what legal victories they can obtain. Then the league will appeal, and the question will be whether the impact of the initial ruling will be sustained during the appeals process. Then the players need to survive the appeals process, and likely more until the league either decides to cave or it runs out of courts to appeal to.

It could take years for the case to wind through the appeals process, something that neither side will want to sustain given the current state of negotiations.

Get player news notifications, manage your team and check scores
- all updated in real time. Download the CBS Fantasy App.

  •  
 
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
COMMENTS
Conversation powered by Livefyre
 
 
Player News
Thunder center Kendrick Perkins returns on Sunday
by Chris Cwik | CBSSports.com
(12/21/2014) Thunder center Kendrick Perkins was able to return to action on Sunday.

Perkins came into the game with a knee injury, and missed Friday's game due to the issue. He was able to log 14 minutes in his return, scoring 4 points. 


Magic forward Tobias Harris injures hand in loss
by Chris Cwik | CBSSports.com
(12/21/2014) Magic forward Tobias Harris injured his hand during the team's win on Sunday, according to the Orlando Sentinel.

Harris was able to notch 38 minutes without any issues, but was spotted after the game with his right hand wrapped. Harris said he hurt his pinkie during the contest. He finished with 17 points. 


Heat guard Dwyane Wade to be re-evaluated on Monday
by Chris Cwik | CBSSports.com
(12/21/2014) Heat guard Dwyane Wade will be re-evaluated on Monday, the team announced.

Wade missed Sunday's game due to a knee injury, but it doesn't seem all that serious. "We just figured it would be best to give him some extra rest," coach Erik Spoelstra said. "We’ll evaluate and see how he feels tomorrow." Wade is averaging 22.8 points per game. 


Timberwolves guard Mo Williams doubles up against the Pacers
by Chris Cwik | CBSSports.com
(12/21/2014) Timberwolves guard Mo Williams posted a double-double on Sunday against the Pacers.

Williams shot 10-16 from the field, including 2-5 from beyond the arc. Williams also hit two free throws during the contest, finishing with 24 points. Williams made sure to get his teammates involved, dishing out 10 assists. 


Pacers' C.J. Miles goes for 28 points on Sunday
by Chris Cwik | CBSSports.com
(12/21/2014) Pacers guard C.J. Miles picked up 28 points off the bench on Sunday.

Miles shot 10-18 from the field, including 4-11 from beyond the arc. He sunk four free throws during the contest. He also added four rebounds. 


Thunder guard Russell Westbrook scores 29 points on Sunday
by Chris Cwik | CBSSports.com
(12/21/2014) Thunder guard Russell Westbrooks scored 29 points on Sunday against the Pelicans.

Westbrook shot 10-27 from the field, but missed all six of his attempts from beyond the arc. He added nine free throws. Westbrook finished with five rebounds, eight assists and three steals. 


Pelicans' Anthony Davis dominates the Thunder on Sunday
by Chris Cwik | CBSSports.com
(12/21/2014) Pelicans forward Anthony Davis dominated the Thunder on Sunday.

Davis shot 16-22 from the field. He added six free throws, finishing with 38 points. Davis was active on the boards, pulling down 12 rebounds. Davis also had two assists and three blocks. 


76ers forward Robert Covington overcomes knee issue on Sunday
by Chris Cwik | CBSSports.com
(12/21/2014) Philadelphia forward Robert Covington overcame a knee injury late in Sunday's game.

Covington briefly left the game late, but was able to return and finish. He played 40 minutes, putting up 11 points and 10 rebounds. It's unclear if Covington will be listed with an injury when the team takes on Miami on Tuesday.


Kings' DeMarcus Cousins doubles up on the Lakers on Sunday
by Chris Cwik | CBSSports.com
(12/21/2014) Kings center DeMarcus Cousins posted a double-double against the Lakers on Sunday.

Cousins shot 9-19 from the field. He got the line 15 times, sinking 11 free throws. Cousins finished with 29 points. He was a monster on the boards, pulling down 14 rebounds. Cousins finished with two steals and two assists. 


Lakers guard Kobe Bryant takes 30 shots on Sunday
by Chris Cwik | CBSSports.com
(12/21/2014) Lakers guard Kobe Bryant threw up 30 shots on Sunday against the Kings.

Bryant hit eight of those 30 attempts, including going 3-8 from beyond the arc. He also sunk all six of his free throws, finishing with 25 points. Bryant added five rebounds and three assists. 


 
 
 
Top Videos
Rankings