Forgot Log-in or  Password? |  Help  Not a member, Register Now!
      
2011 Draft Prep Guide
Fantasy Football Today
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Draft Analyzer
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Red Zone Stats
Teams
Schedules
Scores
Standings
Message Boards
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Premium
Office Pool Manager
Playoff Challenge
2011 Draft Prep Guide
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Rankings
Projections
Teams
Schedules
Weekly Planner
Probable Pitchers
Scores
Standings
Message Boards
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Premium
Downloadable Draft Kit
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injuries
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Message Boards
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Downloadable Draft Kit
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Message Boards
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Premium
Downloadable Draft Kit
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Message Boards
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Premium
No Fantasy Teams Found
 
 

Faceoffs: Addressing the offseason to date

Each week our Dave Richard and Jamey Eisenberg will literally bring their inter-office debating to your computer, explaining why they like one player over another based on a particular week's matchup. As always, we'll try to come up with debates that you might have either with yourself or fellow owners.

Who's the better Fantasy QB: Matt Schaub or David Garrard?
Dave Richard Jamey Eisenberg
Dave Richard As long as I've been playing Fantasy Football, the best quarterbacks are the ones with the best receivers. I think Garrard is a great story, and he's on a strong team, but he still doesn't have an elite wideout he can target 10-to-15 times a game (sorry, Jerry Porter doesn't count). Schaub does have a stud receiver in the form of Andre Johnson, and the two played very well together when they were both healthy last season. Furthermore, Schaub's Texans don't have the running game Garrard's Jaguars have, which means Schaub's arm will be called upon to move the ball more than Garrard's. Throw in Schaub's complementary receivers like Kevin Walter, Andre Davis and tight end Owen Daniels, and he's got the talent around him (and in him, of course) to out-stat Garrard over the course of 2008. Both will be great backups, but I'd pick Schaub first every time. Jamey Eisenberg Chances are you're not drafting Garrard or Schaub to be your starting Fantasy quarterback in 2008. Most likely, one of these two will be your backup with the chance to crack your lineup if he plays well. That was the case with Garrard in 2007. He proved himself as a first-year starter, which is something Schaub still needs to do. He only appeared in 11 games and missed parts of others last year due to injury. I like the upside for Schaub better because he plays with Andre Johnson and Owen Daniels. Schaub could be a legitimate Fantasy stud. But Garrard is the proven commodity, and his receiving corps just got better with the addition of Jerry Porter and Troy Williamson. If you're into taking risks, go with Schaub. If you want a sure thing, Garrard is your man.
Is Michael Turner a viable No. 2 Fantasy RB?
Dave Richard Jamey Eisenberg
Dave Richard By default, Turner is a top-24 Fantasy RB. That said, it's not necessarily because of his talent. Turner is a fast, powerful runner with good hands who will get the chance to be the primary running back for an NFL club in 2008. The issue here is that the club in question is the Falcons, a team that happens to be thin at offensive tackle. Atlanta won't have a strong passing game for Turner to work off of, and he will have to hand off some carries to Jerious Norwood. However, I can't name 24 running backs I'd rather have than Turner (I could definitely name 20 though). Turner will have a shot at totaling well over 1,000 yards in 2008 with goal-line duties, and that's enough to make him a low-end No. 2 Fantasy RB. Expecting anything higher and you're playing with fire; anything lower, and you'd be stealing come Draft Day. Jamey Eisenberg I wish Turner had gone anywhere other than the Falcons. I know he got paid and now has an opportunity to start, but his Fantasy value will be limited in 2008 since Atlanta will be rebuilding. I would consider Turner a solid No. 3 Fantasy option and a good flex player. But I would not draft Turner as a starter. The Falcons don't have a proven quarterback, need work on the offensive line and you can count on Turner sharing carries to some degree with Jerious Norwood. When Dave and I discussed this topic, I told him I'd find 24 running backs I'd take ahead of Turner. Well, here goes: LaDainian Tomlinson, Brian Westbrook, Steven Jackson, Adrian Peterson, Joseph Addai, Clinton Portis, Ryan Grant, Larry Johnson, Frank Gore, Willis McGahee, Willie Parker, Marion Barber, Marshawn Lynch, Maurice Jones-Drew, Earnest Graham, Brandon Jacobs, Laurence Maroney, LenDale White, Travis Henry, Edgerrin James, Reggie Bush, Thomas Jones, Jamal Lewis and DeAngelo Williams. I like Williams as a better breakout candidate than Turner. And if Ronnie Brown (knee) is healthy to start the season, he makes this list also.
Is Bernard Berrian's move to Minnesota good or bad for his Fantasy value?
Dave Richard Jamey Eisenberg
Dave Richard Because of his incredible speed, his deep-ball ability and the Vikings' desperation for wide receiver legitimacy, Berrian will be a good fit. Not only will he play with a Vikings offense that has an incredible run game, but he'll play indoors 10 times in 2008, which will only help support his statistics. Expect him to set a career high in receptions and yards as he attempts to finally give Minnesota their first legit deep threat since Randy Moss. Jamey Eisenberg How can anyone think this is a good move for Berrian? As bad as Rex Grossman was last year, I'd still take him ahead of Tarvaris Jackson as a starting quarterback. Berrian might do well going inside a dome for eight games, but he now plays for a more run-dominated team in Minnesota. Remember Adrian Peterson and Chester Taylor? As for Jackson, he only passed for nine touchdowns in 2007, and the Vikings leaders in the major receiving categories were 54 catches, 647 yards and four touchdowns. While Berrian will help Jackson improve and put up better numbers than whatever Minnesota had last year, going to a better team with a proven quarterback would have improved his Fantasy value instead of bringing it down.
With Donte Stallworth in the fold, is Derek Anderson now a legitimate top 5 Fantasy QB?
Dave Richard Jamey Eisenberg
Dave Richard It's very, very close, but Anderson falls short thanks to some consistent star power at the position. No one will knock Tom Brady from his perch, and Peyton Manning, Tony Romo, Drew Brees and Carson Palmer are just way too reliable to pass on in favor of Anderson, who has had exactly one strong year as a Fantasy mainstay. Granted, Anderson will have the tools to be successful in '08, but the rep of the other five QBs puts them ahead. Anderson is sixth-best in my book. Jamey Eisenberg As of right now, Anderson is No. 6 on our rank list, but I would take him ahead of Carson Palmer and Drew Brees if given the choice. In comparison to Brees, Anderson has better weapons, especially with the addition of Stallworth to go with Braylon Edwards and Kellen Winslow. Brees only has Marques Colston, who is great but not as good as Edwards. And when it comes to Palmer, Anderson and his receivers actually get along. The talent is equal when looking at the overall receiving corps with Cincinnati (Chad Johnson, T.J. Houshmandzadeh and Chris Henry), but Cleveland has a better offensive line. All three will be great, but I like Anderson slightly better in 2008. And in 2007, Anderson (29) had more touchdown passes than Brees (28) and Palmer (26).
Who is your Fantasy DST sleeper as of now?
Dave Richard Jamey Eisenberg
Dave Richard Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. If the 49ers fool me twice, then I guess picking sleeper DSTs isn't my strongsuit. Last year they had the makings of being much improved and fell flat on their faces. This year they've improved via free agency and should do better than their 2007 numbers showed. Jamey Eisenberg You have to like what the Eagles did on the first two days of free agency. Adding DB Asante Samuel will improve their secondary, especially if they can manage to keep Lito Sheppard around. And the addition of DL Chris Clemons will help the pass rush and will be a good replacement for Jevon Kearse. Trent Cole already is a proven commodity on the line, and Omar Gaither is solid at linebacker. Defensive coordinator Jim Johnson should do well with this unit in 2008.

Do you agree with Dave or Jamey? Send your thoughts to DMFantasyFootball@cbs.com and we'll post the best responses. Be sure to put Attn: Fantasy Faceoff in the subject field. Include your full name, hometown and state.

 
 
 
Player News
Matt Schaub
Schaub doing well in rehab
Matt Schaub, QB, HOU
1:03 PM
News: The Houston Chronicle reports Tuesday that Texans QB Matt Schaub, who finished the season on injured reserve following foot surgery, is doing well and his rehab is ahead of schedule. The report says Schaub works out almost every day.
Analysis: This is great news, and we expect Schaub to return at 100 percent in 2012. Continue to monitor what happens with Schaub, but he should be considered a low-end No. 1/high-end No. 2 Fantasy QB heading into the season. He is worth a mid-round pick in all leagues on Draft Day.

Lofa Tatupu
Tatupu visits Saints
Lofa Tatupu, LB, SEA
2:36 PM
News: Free agent LB Lofau Tatupu visited with the Saints on Monday, according to NFL.com. The 29-year-old Tatupu sat out the 2011 season. The former Pro Bowl MLB was asked to take a pay cut by the Seahawks after the lockout ended last summer, and subsequently asked for his release. Tatupu was scheduled to visit with the Raiders and Redskins in August, but didn't sign with anyone and fell off the radar for the remainder of the year while he reportedly dealt with a knee injury. Tatupu was scheduled to earn more than $4 million in 2011 before his release by Seattle. The six-year veteran was a second-round pick and has played in three Pro Bowls. But he also started to wear down from 2008-2010, including finishing 2009 on injured reserve with a knee injury. He did start all 16 games in 2010, but had surgery on both knees during the offseason.
Analysis: Keep an eye on what happens with Tatupu and where he plays in 2012. When healthy and active he could be a No. 3 Fantasy LB worth a late-round pick in IDP leagues.

Ravens
Flacco, Ravens to work on deal
Ravens, TQB BAL,
12:47 PM
News: The NFL Network reports that the Ravens are set to open contract extension talks with QB Joe Flacco's agent at the NFL Combine next week. The report says both sides aim for a long-term deal. Flacco is entering a contract year in 2012, and Ravens owner Steve Bisciotti recently said Flacco would be the team's starting quarterback for years to come.
Analysis: Flacco's won a lot of games for the Ravens but hasn't taken the next step statistically, even when the team added Anquan Boldin and Torrey Smith. Flacco has had between 3,610 and 3,622 passing yards and between 20 and 25 touchdowns in each of his last three seasons. But this year his completion percentage and yards per attempt dropped like a rock while his pass attempts hit a career high (542, breaking the previous mark of 499). Flacco fits the bill as a great No. 2 Fantasy QB; though he's finally outfitted with a quality receiving corps, he simply doesn't invoke much confidence as a starting option. Look for him late in drafts.

Jahvid Best
Best 'on pace' for offseason work
Jahvid Best, RB, DET
12:43 PM
News: The Detroit Free-Press reports that Lions RB Jahvid Best’s status remains uncertain because of concussion problems even though team president Tom Lewand is optimistic. Lewand said Best is "on pace" to be ready for offseason workouts, and he is looking forward to seeing Best and Mikel Leshoure play together. "Jahvid is a special player and he'll be even more dynamic when he can ... share the load with a guy like Mikel in the backfield."
Analysis: We hope Best can return at 100 percent, but he will likely be used as a change of pace rusher and a third-down back. Continue to monitor what happens with Best, but he should only be drafted with a late-round pick in standard leagues and a mid-round selection in PPR formats since he will likely be used in tandem with Leshoure and possibly Kevin Smith if he returns as a free agent.

Mikel Leshoure
Leshoure's recovery going well
Mikel Leshoure, RB, DET
12:40 PM
News: The Detroit Free-Press reports that Lions RB Mikel Leshoure, who tore his left Achilles tendon in the second week of training camp last year, is close to making a full recovery. At the Lions’ request, Leshoure just moved the final stages of his rehab back to Detroit from Arizona. He’s doing resistance work and light running and is expected to join OTA workouts at some point this offseason. Leshoure looked like he was going to be a key part of the Lions offense when injury struck last August, and the team is anxious to get a read on him this spring. RB Jahvid Best’s status remains uncertain because of concussion problems, and even if Best returns it’s clear he’s not an every-down back.
Analysis: Leshoure should be considered a great sleeper heading into 2012, and he is worth drafting as a No. 3 Fantasy RB as long as he's healthy. He has tremendous upside, and he could be a great weapon for the Lions, especially with Best struggling as an every-down back. Continue to monitor what happens with Leshoure, but he is worth drafting as early as Round 6 in 2012.

Mike Wallace
Steelers want to lock up Wallace
Mike Wallace, WR, PIT
12:17 PM
News: The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reports that Steelers GM Kevin Colbert said Monday the team wants to keep WR Mike Wallace "here for the long run." Wallace, their leading receiver last season, will become a restricted free agent March 13.
Analysis: Wallace played well in 2011 with 72 catches for 1,193 yards and eight touchdowns on 114 targets. He will remain in Pittsburgh in 2012, and hopefully he can sign a long-term deal. We consider Wallace a Top 10 Fantasy WR on Draft Day, and he should be selected in all leagues in Round 3.

Hines Ward
GM says no decision on Ward yet
Hines Ward, WR, PIT
12:13 PM
News: The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reports that Steelers GM Kevin Colbert said Monday that no decision has been made on whether WR Hines Ward will be back with the Steelers in 2012. "To this current point, no final decisions have been made," Colbert said. "We've had several discussions internally. We're right in the midst of our free agent evaluations of other teams' free agents. We'll meet on those [on the Steelers roster] starting Thursday and carry through Monday." A recent report on NFL Network said that Ward won't be back with the Steelers in 2012 but a source close to Ward refuted the report.
Analysis: Keep an eye on what happens with Ward and where he ends up in 2012. No matter where Ward plays, however, he would have minimal Fantasy value, and he is not worth drafting in the majority of leagues.

Brandon Lloyd
Pats could go after Lloyd
Brandon Lloyd, WR, STL
12:08 PM
News: The Boston Herald reports that the Patriots will be in the market for a WR this year, and one obvious possibility is Brandon Lloyd, who is an impending free agent, because of his ties to offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels. The fact that Lloyd said “I’m tied to McDaniels” makes him a likely free agent target. Lloyd had 51 catches for 683 yards and five TDs last year in 11 games in St. Louis when McDaniels was the offensive coordinator makes him look pretty good after he amassed 77 catches for 1,448 yards and 11 scores with Denver when McDaniels was the coach.
Analysis: One holdup for Lloyd and the Patriots could be Lloyd's agent, Tom Condon, who has a rocky relationship with the Patriots. We'll see what plays out this offseason, but if Lloyd signs in New England he would be considered a low-end No. 2 Fantasy WR. He could still return to the Rams, where he would be a strong No. 3 option. Or he could shop himself around the league. Stay tuned, but either way Lloyd is worth a mid-round pick in all leagues.

Bills
Fitzpatrick finished season hurt
Bills, TQB BUF,
11:53 AM
News: The Sports Xchange reports that Bills QB Ryan Fitzpatrick's second-half swoon in 2011 was mystifying to fans and media who concluded the front office badly miscalculated in handing the career journeyman a 10-year, $60 million contract extension. But now it appears Fitzpatrick played the final nine games last season with cracked ribs. "A lot of people don't know, but Fitz, during the Washington game, actually cracked a couple of ribs," WR David Nelson said. "So after that he was playing hurt." It showed. In Fitzpatrick's first seven games of the year, he threw for 1,739 yards, 14 touchdowns and seven interceptions. After the injury, he had 2,093 yards, 10 touchdowns and 16 picks. He finished the year with a league-high 23 interceptions. "It's hard to find the silver lining but as we evaluate the season and what went right and what went wrong I'm sure we'll find a lot of positives and a lot of things that we can carry into next year hopefully and continue to get better at it," Fitzpatrick said.
Analysis: Fitzpatrick obviously has 4,000-yard, 25-touchdown potential, but issues involving the personnel around him along with his own issues (accuracy, for one) make him risky for weekly use in Fantasy. Figure that he's worth a late-round pick as a good No. 2 Fantasy QB with potential to be a low-end starter. It should only help him if the Bills not only re-sign Steve Johnson this offseason, but also add talent at wide receiver.

Josh Scobee
Jags want Scobee back
Josh Scobee, K, JAC
11:47 AM
News: The Sports Xchange reports that Jacksonville has most of its top offensive players locked into contracts for the coming season with one notable exception - kicker Josh Scobee, who is an eight-year veteran. Scobee has been one of the league's most accurate kickers in his eight seasons with the Jaguars, converting better than 75 percent of his field-goal attempts in all but one season. Scobee led the team in scoring last year with 92 points, including 23 of 25 (92 percent) field-goal attempts, the second time in his career he's finished over 90 percent with his kicks. It isn't likely the Jaguars would use the franchise tag on him and probably won't have to. They'll make every attempt to sign him. For a team that was among the league's lowest scoring clubs, the Jaguars can ill afford to lose a player with Scobee's talents.
Analysis: Keep an eye on what happens with Scobee. He is not worth drafting in the majority of leagues, but he could be used as a bye-week replacement as long as he remains with the Jaguars.

 
 
 
Top Videos
Rankings