Forgot Log-in or  Password? |  Help  Not a member, Register Now!
      
Fantasy Football Today
Gameday Inactives
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Get Your Draft Board
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Red Zone Stats
Teams
Schedules
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Premium
Office Pool Manager
Playoff Challenge
Fantasy Baseball Today
2013 Draft Prep Guide
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Rankings
Projections
Teams
Schedules
Probable Pitchers
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injuries
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Message Boards
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Downloadable Draft Kit
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Premium
Downloadable Draft Kit
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Premium
No Fantasy Teams Found
 
 

Which positions were the most valuable in 2009?

Dave Richard
Senior Fantasy Writer
  •  

Were quarterbacks the most valuable position in Fantasy Football last year? What about top-tier receivers versus No. 2 Fantasy running backs? How do the tiers among each position fare against each other?

You can get your answers here. We broke down each Fantasy position into groups of 12 based on how they finished in standard scoring formats, then averaged their weekly numbers. If you try and compare them all at once you won't learn anything, but if you filter by position and by the varying tiers, your jaw might drop from what you learn. Our talking points come after the chart. If at any time you want to re-start your session, click the circular arrow at the bottom.

What we learned

• There was minimal variance between the top 36 wide receivers on a week to week basis. Sure, the Top 12 receivers typically averaged the most points but the difference between their production and the receivers ranked 25th through 36th wasn't overly huge other than for a couple of weeks. That essentially goes for the receivers ranked 13th through 24th as well.

• Top-tier quarterbacks were far and away the most productive in Fantasy this season (an argument against awarding six points for a passing touchdown, perhaps?). But in eight of the 17 weeks second-tier quarterbacks finished better than top-tier running backs. Again, we're probably making the case that passing touchdowns are overvalued since David Garrard and Jason Campbell amassed more Fantasy points than Ray Rice and Thomas Jones.

• Are you better off drafting your second running back before your first receiver? As it turns out, it's a coin flip: Second-tier rushers ranked higher than top-tier receivers in eight of 17 weeks and those receivers outperformed the running backs in eight weeks with a tie in Week 13. Based on this, feel free to pick your poison in Rounds 2 and 3 (or let how the draft dictate who you choose).

• The logic also applies when comparing No. 3 running backs to No. 2 wide receivers. Receivers outperformed them in most weeks, but not by much.

• Remember this chart the next time you think about reaching for a tight end: The top 12 tight ends were essentially on par with third-tier rushers and receivers. By this logic, no tight end should be taken before the middle rounds of a draft. While this might speak to the proverbial logjam we saw among the bottom-half of No. 1 tight ends in 2009, it sure seems like spending an early choice on Dallas Clark or Vernon Davis next season could be a bad move.

• DSTs are typically picked toward the end of drafts, but this chart proves just how valuable they are as they equaled or outscored top-tier receivers in 13 of the 17 weeks. Does this mean we should be drafting DST units in Rounds 3 and 4? Nope -- remember, there are 32 DSTs and anywhere from 10 to 14 owners in each Fantasy league. Supply grossly outweighs demand.

• Same thing for placekickers, even though they are essentially on par with running backs ranked 37th through 48th and receivers ranked 25th through 36th.

•The least valuable tiers in '09? Low-end running backs (57-plus) and tight ends ranked 25th through 36th. This should impact no one as running backs and tight ends that produce minimal Fantasy points shouldn't be touched anyway.

Did anything stand out to you in this visualization? What did you learn? Share it with us by e-mailing us at dmfantasyfootball@cbs.com. Be sure to put Attn: Positional Tiers in the subject field. Please include your full name, hometown and state.

  •  
 
CBSSports Facebook Twitter
COMMENTS
Conversation powered by Livefyre
 
 
Player News
Steve Smith
Smith working hard in offseason
Steve Smith, WR, CAR
5/24/2013
News: The Charlotte Observer reports that Panthers coach Ron Rivera said receiver Steve Smith has looked like he's 25 again during OTAs. The report says Rivera said the veteran wideout has been diving for balls, and even though it's more than three months from Week 1, he still shows his frustration when the ball doesn't come his way.
Analysis: Smith will be 34 when the season starts, which will be his 13th in the NFL. It's a good sign he's this excited for the season, and we hope he has a big year. In 2012, Smith had 73 catches for 1,174 yards and four touchdowns, but he has the chance to improve on those stats, especially the touchdowns. Plan on drafting him in Round 5 or 6 in the majority of leagues.

Ricardo Lockette
Lockette has chance to start
Ricardo Lockette, WR, SF
5/24/2013
News: Comcast Sports Net reports that A.J. Jenkins, Quinton Patton and Ricardo Lockette will compete during the remainder of the 49ers' offseason program to replace injured receiver Michael Crabtree (Achilles), coach Jim Harbaugh said Friday on a radio interview. "We'll put Jenkins, Patton, Ricardo Lockette at the same position and let them compete and emerge," Harbaugh said. "The good news is somebody will emerge because they have to."
Analysis: Lockette could emerge as the starter with Crabtree out, but we'd expect him to be No. 3 at best of this group. That also doesn't take into account Mario Manningham potentially coming back. Keep an eye on what happens with Lockette this offseason, but even if he starts he would just be a late-round flier in deeper formats.

Quinton Patton
Patton in mix to start
Quinton Patton, WR, SF
5/24/2013
News: Comcast Sports Net reports that A.J. Jenkins, Quinton Patton and Ricardo Lockette will compete during the remainder of the 49ers' offseason program to replace injured receiver Michael Crabtree (Achilles), coach Jim Harbaugh said Friday on a radio interview. "We'll put Jenkins, Patton, Ricardo Lockette at the same position and let them compete and emerge," Harbaugh said. "The good news is somebody will emerge because they have to."
Analysis: Patton could emerge as the starter for the 49ers, but we'd be surprised if he's the guy called on to replace Crabtree in his rookie season. Keep an eye on what develops, but Patton would only be worth drafting with a late-round flier in deeper leagues. In rookie-only formats, Patton is worth a mid-round pick.

A.J. Jenkins
Jenkins has chance to start
A.J. Jenkins, WR, SF
5/24/2013
News: Comcast Sports Net reports that A.J. Jenkins, Quinton Patton and Ricardo Lockette will compete during the remainder of the 49ers' offseason program to replace injured receiver Michael Crabtree (Achilles), coach Jim Harbaugh said Friday on a radio interview. "We'll put Jenkins, Patton, Ricardo Lockette at the same position and let them compete and emerge," Harbaugh said. "The good news is somebody will emerge because they have to."
Analysis: Jenkins is the early favorite of the group mentioned to start in place of Crabtree, but keep an eye on what develops. Jenkins went his entire rookie season without a catch in 2012, so he has a lot to prove before Fantasy owners can count on him. If he does win the starting job opposite Anquan Boldin he would be a late-round flier at best in standard leagues.

Mike Gillislee
Excitement building over Gillislee
Mike Gillislee, RB, MIA
5/24/2013
News: The Miami Herald reports that even though the Dolphins "love" Lamar Miller and have Daniel Thomas, who "sees himself as the successor to (Reggie) Bush," the darkhorse candidate to carry the running game is rookie Mike Gillislee. The report says "there is an internal excitement about him. There is hope he can factor and perhaps even surprise everyone." Gillislee was drafted in the fifth round this year out of Florida.
Analysis: We fully expect Miller to start, but he has limited experience. And Thomas, as much as he expects to win the starting job, could easily fall to third on the depth chart. The South Florida Sun Sentinel previously suggested Gillislee will compete for the starting job, and we can see him being a factor this season. Put him on your sleeper list and draft him with a late-round flier. In rookie-only formats take a chance on Gillislee with a second-round pick.

Anthony McCoy
McCoy has torn Achilles
Anthony McCoy, TE, SEA
5/24/2013
News: NFL Network reported Seahawks tight end Anthony McCoy had surgery to repair a partially torn Achilles suffered during the Seahawks' recent OTA practices. Per the report, McCoy tore the Achilles while running.
Analysis: This should seal Zach Miller as the Seahawks' most threatening tight end and rookie Luke Wilson as his backup. McCoy was never a consideration for Fantasy in the first place and might be done for the year if the Seahawks don't want to wait for him to come back from his rehab.

Roy Helu
Helu out during OTAs
Roy Helu, RB, WAS
5/24/2013
News: The Washington Post reports that Redskins running back Roy Helu is sitting out OTA workouts this week as he continues to recover from last year's toe injury. The report says Helu also is dealing with an Achilles injury.
Analysis: Helu has work to do if he wants to earn the No. 2 job behind Alfred Morris. He will face competition from rookie Chris Thompson for third-down work, and Evan Royster is also in the mix to be the top backup. Keep an eye on Helu's recovery, and he would only be worth a late-round flier at best if he's back at 100 percent by training camp.

Randy Moss
49ers haven't contacted Moss
Randy Moss, WR, SF
5/24/2013
News: CBSSports.com NFL Insider Mike Freeman reports that the 49ers haven't contacted free agent receiver Randy Moss following the injury to Michael Crabtree (Achilles). Freeman reports that Moss left the 49ers on good terms following his one season there in 2012.
Analysis: Keep an eye on what happens with Moss and if a team will be willing to take a chance on him. If he signs with the 49ers or somewhere else, his Fantasy value will be determined on his role and his quarterback. He could be worth a late-round pick, but Moss' best days are definitely behind him.

Aaron Dobson
Dobson draws favorable comparison
Aaron Dobson, WR, NE
5/24/2013
News: The Boston Globe reports that NFL Films senior producer Greg Cosell "is a big fan" of Patriots rookie receiver Aaron Dobson, who was drafted in the second round out of Marshall. “This is going to sound crazy, but I thought that his size/hand combination, at times, reminded me of Larry Fitzgerald,” Cosell said. “He’s not Larry Fitzgerald, obviously, but he’s a big kid who can move very well with really good hands.”
Analysis: Dobson is 6-foot-3, 203 pounds and made plenty of highlight-reel catches at Marshall. In each of his last three seasons in colege, Dobson had at least 44 catches and 668 yards receiving. He had 12 touchdown catches in 2011. His 24 career touchdown receptions tie former Patriot Troy Brown for fourth most in Marshall history. If Dobson earns a starting job he would be worth a late-round flier in all leagues. He's worth at least a second-round pick in rookie-only formats.

Mike Goodson
Goodson says he'll practice next week
Mike Goodson, RB, NYJ
5/24/2013
News: The New York Daily News reports Jets running back Mike Goodson expects to practice next week. He didn't practice this week in the wake of being arrested on drug and weapons charges. A hearing is scheduled for June 12.
Analysis: Maybe the Jets are planning to have Goodson as part of their plan for 2013 after all. Between the courts and the league there's no guarantee that Goodson will play for all of the 2013 season. For now owners shouldn't have him on their radars, though if his attorney is as innocent as he suggests, that would change before the majority of people hold their Fantasy drafts.

 
 
 
Top Videos
Rankings