Forgot Log-in or  Password? |  Help  Not a member, Register Now!
      
Fantasy Football Today
Fantasy Football Today Blog
Gameday Inactives
2014 Draft Prep Guide
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Get Your Draft Board
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Schedules
Scores
Fantasy Games
Playoff Challenge
Commissioner
Prize Leagues
Free
Office Pool Manager
Game Pick'em
Player Challenge
Fantasy Baseball Today
Fantasy Baseball Today Blog
2015 Draft Prep Guide
Mock Drafts
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Rankings
Projections
Schedules
Probable Pitchers
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injuries
Projections
Rankings
Schedules
Message Boards
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
Downloadable Draft Kit
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
No Fantasy Teams Found
 
 
 

2012 Draft Prep: Setting the offensive lines

Senior Fantasy Writer
  •  

For each of the last three seasons, I've taken up the task of grading starting linemen one by one and assigning a letter grade like the kind you see on a typical school report card, calculating the average and then rank them accordingly. The point of it is to give you an idea of which offensive lines are expected to be strong and which ones will be weak.

 
Team
GPA '12 Grade
1 Carolina Panthers 2.868 B
2 New Orleans Saints 2.86 B
3 New York Jets 2.8 B
4 New England Patriots 2.73 B
5 Philadelphia Eagles 2.66 B-
5 San Francisco 49ers 2.66 B-
7 Baltimore Ravens 2.6 B-
7 Tampa Bay Buccaneers 2.6 B-
7 Tennessee Titans 2.6 B-
7 Cincinnati Bengals 2.6 B-
7 Pittsburgh Steelers 2.6 B-
12 Houston Texans 2.53 C+
12 Kansas City Chiefs 2.53 C+
14 Cleveland Browns 2.4 C+
14 Green Bay Packers 2.4 C+
14 Minnesota Vikings 2.4 C+
14 Atlanta Falcons 2.4 C+
14 Detroit Lions 2.396 C+
19 Miami Dolphins 2.33 C+
20 Jacksonville Jaguars 2.2 C
21 Dallas Cowboys 2.134 C
21 Buffalo Bills 2.134 C
23 Denver Broncos 2.0 C
23 San Diego Chargers 2.0 C
23 St. Louis Rams 2.0 C
23 Oakland Raiders 2.0 C
27 Washington Redskins 1.93 C-
27 Seattle Seahawks 1.93 C-
29 Arizona Cardinals 1.8 C-
30 New York Giants 1.6 C-
30 Indianapolis Colts 1.6 C-
32 Chicago Bears 1.4 D+

Over the last few seasons I came to the conclusion that the overwhelming majority of O-lines around the NFL effectively grade out similarly. Some were noticeably better than the rest, some were noticeably worse, but the majority were bunched together.

So in an effort to change that "bunching" I made some changes to my system. For instance, you'll find several instances where two linemen are graded for one spot. This might be because two guys are fighting for a job in camp or the starter isn't expected to make it through most of the season and the backup needs to be addressed. When you see two players listed in one spot, the expected starter is named to the left of the slash and the grade is a cumulative total for both men. Additionally, I was more aggressive in grading linemen this season, dishing out more D's than ever before (I even doled out an F). I also gave credit to O-lines that worked in the same system for multiple seasons with at least three returning starters.

Also, in an attempt to provide as accurate of a grade as possible, and to make sure I didn't provide a list of 32 teams with the exact same grade, I cross-referenced my notes with the 2011 evaluations at ProFootballFocus.com .

And after all of these measures were taken, the following conclusion was reached: the overwhelming majority of O-lines around the NFL effectively grade out similarly.

There's no sugar-coating this, no way to make the list more attractive without going against my notes (or ProFootballFocus' notes). Let's just put it this way: If we had to draft individual offensive linemen in Fantasy, we might end up reaching for the best ones.

You'll find all of the information about every offensive line below. Keep in mind that no rookie lineman is eligible for a grade higher than a B and there is no weighting for blind-side tackles or Pro Bowlers. A line is as strong as its weakest link.

The grades should provide some food for thought. Use this guide as a potential tiebreaker between quarterbacks and running backs throughout your draft. For instance, if you're debating between Carson Palmer and Andy Dalton, maybe Dalton has an edge because his O-line graded out better. Or if you're looking at the lesser of two evils between Donald Brown and James Starks, at least Starks' line has some continuity and a better grade.

Arizona Cardinals
Returning Starters: 3
LT LG C RG RT
Levi Brown Daryn Colledge Lyle Sendlein Adam Snyder B. Massie/J. Bridges
C+ C C D C-
Cumulative GPA: 1.8 (C-)
Atlanta Falcons
Returning Starters: 4
LT LG C RG RT
Sam Baker Justin Blalock Todd McClure Jameson Konz Tyson Clabo
D+ C B- C+ A-
Cumulative GPA: 2.4 (C+)
Baltimore Ravens
Returning Starters: 4
LT LG C RG RT
Bryant McKinnie Bobbie Williams Matt Birk Marshal Yanda Michael Oher
C- B B- B+ C+
Cumulative GPA: 2.6 (C+)
Buffalo Bills
Returning Starters: 4
LT LG C RG RT
C. Hairston/C. Glenn Andy Levitre Eric Wood Kraig Urbik Erik Pears
C B- C- C C+
Cumulative GPA: 2.134 (C)
Carolina Panthers
Returning Starters: 4
LT LG C RG RT
Jordan Gross A. Silatolu/M. Pollak Ryan Kalil Geoff Hangartner Byron Bell
A- C A- B+ C-
Cumulative GPA: 2.868 (B-)
Chicago Bears
Returning Starters: 4
LT LG C RG RT
J. Webb/C. Williams Chris Spencer Roberto Garza C. Rachal/L. Louis Gabe Carimi
D+ D+ C- D C-
Cumulative GPA: 1.4 (D+)
Cincinnati Bengals
Returning Starters: 3
LT LG C RG RT
Andrew Whitworth Travelle Wharton Kyle Cook Kevin Zeitler Andre Smith
A C- C+ B C
Cumulative GPA: 2.6 (C+)
Cleveland Browns
Returning Starters: 4
LT LG C RG RT
Joe Thomas Jason Pinkston Alex Mack Shawn Lauvao M. Schwartz/O. Cousins
A- C- B+ C- C-
Cumulative GPA: 2.4 (C+)
Dallas Cowboys
Returning Starters: 3
LT LG C RG RT
Tyron Smith Nate Livings Phil Costa Mackenzy Bernadeau Doug Free
B C C- C C
Cumulative GPA: 2.134 (C)
Denver Broncos
Returning Starters: 5
LT LG C RG RT
Ryan Clady Zane Beadles J.D. Walton/P. Blake Chris Kuper Orlando Franklin
B+ D+ D- C B-
Cumulative GPA: 2.0 (C)
Detroit Lions
Returning Starters: 5
LT LG C RG RT
Jeff Backus Rob Sims Dominic Raiola Stephen Peterman Gosder Cherilus
B- B- B C C-
Cumulative GPA: 2.4 (C+)
Green Bay Packers
Returning Starters: 3
LT LG C RG RT
Marshall Newhouse T.J. Lang Jeff Saturday Josh Sitton Bryan Bulaga
D+ B- B B- C+
Cumulative GPA: 2.4 (C+)
Houston Texans
Returning Starters: 3
LT LG C RG RT
Duane Brown Wade Smith Chris Myers B. Brooks/A. Caldwell Rashad Butler
B+ C+ A C- D+
Cumulative GPA: 2.532 (C+)
Indianapolis Colts
Returning Starters: 1
LT LG C RG RT
Anthony Castonzo J. Reitz/B. Ijalana Samson Satele Mike McGlynn Winston Justice
C D+ C D+ D+
Cumulative GPA: 1.6 (C-)
Jacksonville Jaguars
Returning Starters: 5
LT LG C RG RT
Eugene Monroe Will Rackley Brad Meester Uche Nwaneri Eben Britton
B+ D- B C C
Cumulative GPA: 2.2 (C)
Kansas City Chiefs
Returning Starters: 3
LT LG C RG RT
Branden Albert Ryan Lilja Rodney Hudson Jon Asamoah Eric Winston
B- B- C- C+ B+
Cumulative GPA: 2.53 (C+)
Miami Dolphins
Returning Starters: 3
LT LG C RG RT
Jake Long Richie Incognito Mike Pouncey Artis Hicks Jonathan Martin
A- C B D+ C-
Cumulative GPA: 2.33 (C+)
Minnesota Vikings
Returning Starters: 3
LT LG C RG RT
Matt Kalil J. Berger/C. Johnson John Sullivan Brandon Fusco Phil Loadholt
B C- B+ D+ B-
Cumulative GPA: 2.4 (C+)
New England Patriots
Returning Starters: TBD
LT LG C RG RT
Nate Solder L. Mankins/R. Gallery D. Connolly/D. Koppen Brian Waters S. Vollmer/M. Cannon
B- B+ C+ B C+
Cumulative GPA: 2.73 (B-)
New Orleans Saints
Returning Starters: 4
LT LG C RG RT
Jermon Bushrod Ben Grubbs Brian De La Puente Jahri Evans Charles Brown
B+ B+ C+ B+ C
Cumulative GPA: 2.86 (B-)
New York Giants
Returning Starters: 5
LT LG C RG RT
Will Beatty Kevin Boothe David Baas Chris Snee David Diehl
C D C- C+ D
Cumulative GPA: 1.6 (C-)
New York Jets
Returning Starters: 5
LT LG C RG RT
D'Brickashaw Ferguson Matt Slauson Nick Mangold Brandon Moore J. Otah/W. Hunter
B+ C A+ B D+
Cumulative GPA: 2.8 (B-)
Oakland Raiders
Returning Starters: 4
LT LG C RG RT
Jared Veldheer Cooper Carlisle Stefen Wisniewski Mike Brisiel Khalif Barnes
B- D+ C B- D+
Cumulative GPA: 2.0 (C)
Philadelphia Eagles
Returning Starters: 3
LT LG C RG RT
Demetress Bell Evan Mathis Jason Kelce Danny Watkins Todd Herremans
C+ A+ C+ D+ B
Cumulative GPA: 2.66 (B-)
Pittsburgh Steelers
Returning Starters: 3
LT LG C RG RT
Mike Adams Willie Colon Maurkice Pouncey David DeCastro M. Gilbert/M. Starks
C- B- B+ B C+
Cumulative GPA: 2.6 (C+)
San Diego Chargers
Returning Starters: 5
LT LG C RG RT
Jared Gaither Tyronne Green Nick Hardwick Louis Vasquez J. Clary/M. Henderson
B+ D B C D-
Cumulative GPA: 2.0 (C)
Seattle Seahawks
Returning Starters: 4
LT LG C RG RT
Russell Okung Paul McQuistan Max Unger J. Moffitt/D. Lutui Breno Giacomini
C C- B+ D C-
Cumulative GPA: 1.93 (C-)
San Francisco 49ers
Returning Starters: 4
LT LG C RG RT
Joe Staley Mike Iupati Jonathan Goodwin Alex Boone Anthony Davis
B+ A C+ C C-
Cumulative GPA: 2.66 (B-)
St. Louis Rams
Returning Starters: 3
LT LG C RG RT
Rodger Saffold B. Mattison/R. Watkins Scott Wells Harvey Dahl Jason Smith
C- F A- B+ D+
Cumulative GPA: 2.0 (C)
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Returning Starters: 4
LT LG C RG RT
Donald Penn Carl Nicks Jeremy Zuttah Davin Joseph Jeremy Trueblood
B A+ C+ C+ D
Cumulative GPA: 2.6 (B-)
Tennessee Titans
Returning Starters: 4
LT LG C RG RT
Michael Roos Steve Hutchinson Eugene Amano Leroy Harris David Stewart
B+ A- D+ C B-
Cumulative GPA: 2.6 (B-)
Washington Redskins
Returning Starters: 5
LT LG C RG RT
Trent Williams Kory Lichtensteiger Will Montgomery Chris Chester Jammal Brown
C+ B- C C- D
Cumulative GPA: 1.93 (C-)

Stay in touch with the most passionate Fantasy staff in the business by following us via Twitter @CBSFantasyFB . You can also follow Dave at @daverichard and on Facebook .

Get player news notifications, manage your team and check scores
- all updated in real time. Download the CBS Fantasy App.

  •  
 
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
COMMENTS
Conversation powered by Livefyre
 
 
Player News
NFL receives permission for photos in Greg Hardy investigation
by Brandon Wise | CBSSports.com
(2:32 pm ET) The NFL has obtained permission to access photos submitted into evidence for Cowboys defensive end Greg Hardy's domestic violence case, according to ESPN.com.

A judge in North Carolina signed off on all parties, including the NFL and NFLPA, involved in the case to have access to photos of alleged assault against Hardy's former girlfriend, without the district attorney giving up custody of the images. 

A decision from the NFL in Hardy's case has yet to be handed down, but is expected to be announced soon, according to ESPN's Ed Werder. The images in the assault case will help the league determine punishment to be handed down on Hardy, who signed a one-year deal with Dallas this offseason.

"We are trying to get as many facts as we possibly can to make the most informed decision we can so that we can uphold standards that we put forward in our personal conduct policy," NFL commissioner Roger Goodell said last week at the owners meeting. "So I expect that that will conclude sometime in the near future and we'll make a decision shortly after."


Ravens' Matt Schaub: 'I've got a lot more football left in me'
by Igor Mello | CBSSports.com
(2:29 pm ET) Newly acquired Ravens quarterback Matt Schaub told reporters during a phone conference that his elbow is "fine" and that he has plenty of football left in him, per the Baltimore Sun.

"I had a rough year. I learned from it. I've got a lot more football left in me," Schaub said. "I know what I'm capable of. It's just a matter of finding the right opportunity."

Schaub, 33, registered only 10 pass attempts last season for the Raiders. The veteran, however, has completed 63.9 percent of his passes in his career while racking up 130 touchdowns and 86 interceptions. He won 40 games in a five-year stretch (2008-12) with the Texans.

Schaub will serve as a backup to starter Joe Flacco next season.

"In this role as a backup, you still have to mentally and physically get yourself ready to play. You never know," Schaub said.


Bears sign linebacker Sam Acho to one-year contract
by Brandon Wise | CBSSports.com
(2:11 pm ET) The Bears have signed linebacker Sam Acho to a one-year contract, the team announced Wednesday. 

Acho spent the last  four seasons with the Cardinals, totaling 124 tackles with 13 sacks and three interceptions in 51 games. Acho played every game for Arizona in three of the four seasons.


Report: Stevan Ridley meeting with the Jets on Wednesday
by Igor Mello | CBSSports.com
(1:19 pm ET) Former Patriots running back Stevan Ridley visited another AFC East team on Wednesday -- the Jets, according to Adam Schefter of ESPN. Ridley, a free agent, visited the Dolphins a day before his visit with the Jets.

Ridely tore his ACL in the sixth game last season and finished with 340 rushing yards and two touchdowns. He has rushed for 2,817 yards and 22 touchdowns in his four-year career with the Patriots.

>> Want more NFL offseason? >> Mock drafts | Free agency tracker


Report: Romo restructures deal, saves Cowboys $13M in cap space
by Michael Hurcomb | CBSSports.com
(1:07 pm ET) Cowboys quarterback Tony Romo has restructured his contract, according to Yahoo Sports. He will save the Cowboys $13 million in salary cap space.

Romo indicated in a radio interview Tuesday he was going to restructure his contract and also said he was willing to take a pay cut so the team could re-sign running back DeMarco Murray, who eventually signed with the Eagles.

"DeMarco ended up asking me, 'Why don't you take a pay cut?' I said, 'I will. I would take a pay cut to go do this,'" Romo said. "I was like, 'They're going to restructure me.' That's the same thing in some ways, just for the salary cap purposes. He was like, 'OK, now we're back to being friends again.' I would take $5 million less if it meant getting him back.

"He knew that. It was just funny how he was literally worried about that part of it for a week. I'm like, 'That's not the reason.' I'm like, 'Obviously I'll restructure. I would even take a pay cut.' He was like, 'OK, we can be friends again.' It's amazing what you think about in those moments."

Romo's restructuring does clear up enough cap space for the Cowboys to potentially make a run at trading for Vikings running back Adrian Peterson, who is slated to make $12.75 million in base salary in 2015, per ProFootballTalk.com.

Peterson's name has been linked to the Cowboys in the past, including Peterson's dad -- Nelson Peterson -- mentioning in late February he's heard rumors of Peterson being potentially traded to the Cowboys, Cardinals or Colts.


Dan Herron signs exclusive rights tender with Colts
by Igor Mello | CBSSports.com
(12:42 pm ET) Colts running back Dan Herron signed his exclusive rights tender on Wednesday, according to the Herald Bulletin. Herron started three of 16 games for the Colts in the regular season, and all three postseason games. The 26-year-old rushed for 351 yards and one touchdown on 78 carries. He rushed for 170 yards on the ground in the postseason.

Saints sign cornerback Kyle Wilson
by Sean d'Oliveira | CBSSports.com
(11:55 am ET) The Saints agreed to terms with cornerback Kyle Wilson on Wednesday, the team announced.

Details of the contract were not disclosed. Wilson spent the last five seasons playing for the Jets. In 2014, he totaled 26 tackles and one sack. He has three career interceptions.


Saints extend contract of guard Jahri Evans
by Sean d'Oliveira | CBSSports.com
(11:51 am ET)  The Saints announced Wednesday they extended the contract of offensive guard Jahri Evans by one year.

The Saints were hoping to rework his contract to create more cap space. Evans has started all but two games for the Saints over the last nine seasons.


Malcolm Jenkins: Eagles players not surprised by McCoy trade
by Michael Hurcomb | CBSSports.com
(11:12 am ET) While most folks were shocked when the news broke in early March the Eagles were trading running back LeSean McCoy to the Bills, apparently McCoy's Philadelphia teammates were not

Safety Malcolm Jenkins told NFL Network on Wednesday it was not surprising when it was announced McCoy was being traded for linebacker Kiko Alonso.

"In the locker room a lot of guys weren't surprised by the trade, what we were more surprised of was that it was just a player-for-player trade," Jenkins said. "I think everybody thought we would have gotten more -- Kiko, plus a couple draft picks, you know, somebody else...

"You look at the style of runner that Chip wants in his offense and even though Shady is one of the best backs in the league, he's not necessarily what Chip is looking for all the time. Chip thinks he's a great running back, he knows his talent is there, but our (system) is really predicated on downhill, somebody who is going to hit the hole every time. It's about getting up in the defenders face as fast as you can and that's not necessarily Shady's running style."

The Eagles replaced McCoy's absence in the backfield by signing former Cowboys running back DeMarco Murray, who rushed for 1,845 yards in 2014, and former Chargers running back Ryan Mathews.

"When you talk about what you can get for -- if you are looking to acquire more talent -- I just think Shady's cap number and what we were able to get in return for Shady, I think made sense," Jenkins said. "And some guys in the locker room who kind of know what's going on weren't surprised by it."


Joe Lombardi: Lions excited to see what Broyles does in offseason
by Michael Hurcomb | CBSSports.com
(10:57 am ET) The Lions are not yet giving up on wide receiver Ryan Broyles, who has been hampered in his career by knee and Achilles injuries. 

“I think he’s a guy you have a lot of respect for because he’s had three major injuries and fought his way back,’’ Lions offensive coordinator Joe Lombardi said Tuesday, per The Oakland Press. “When he’s been in there he’s been productive. We’re excited to see where he is now after a full season of not coming back from an injury. He’s had a full year to be healthy we’re excited to see what he does in the offseasaon.’’


 
 
 
Rankings