Forgot Log-in or  Password? |  Help  Not a member, Register Now!
Play Fantasy The Most Award Winning Fantasy game with real time scoring, top expert analysis, custom settings, and more. Play Now
      
Fantasy Football Today
2014 Draft Prep Guide
Gameday Inactives
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Get Your Draft Board
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Red Zone Stats
Teams
Schedules
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Playoff Challenge
Commissioner
Prize Leagues
Free
Office Pool Manager
Game Pick'em
Player Challenge
Fantasy Baseball Today
2014 Draft Prep Guide
Downloadable Draft Kit
Mock Drafts
Player News
Stats
Players
Depth Charts
Roster Trends
Columns
Injury Report
Rankings
Projections
Teams
Schedules
Probable Pitchers
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injuries
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Message Boards
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
Downloadable Draft Kit
Player News
Stats
Players
Columns
Injury Report
Projections
Rankings
Teams
Schedules
Mock Drafts
Scores
Standings
Fantasy Games
Commissioner
Free
Prize Leagues
No Fantasy Teams Found
 
 
 

Reality Check: Stop your QB carousel

Senior Fantasy Writer
  •  

It was a different world, Week 2.

Back then, spirits were high. Optimism rampant. Hair out of control. Expectations unwieldy.

We all thought we could predict the future, man.

It was in those days of reckless self-assurance that I had the audacity to unfurl this gem:

"With so little differentiation between the second and third tiers at quarterback now, the position, quite frankly, has become matchups-oriented."

I wrote it. You read it. We've been banging our heads against a wall ever since.

Not that it was so outlandish at the time. The general premise of a less-than-elite super tier developing at the position has proven to be true, with fewer points separating the 11th quarterback from the third quarterback than the third quarterback from the second. But after eight weeks of experimenting with it, I can confidently say that playing matchups at quarterback simply won't do -- a possibility I foresaw but didn't fully embrace in that Sept. 19 column:

"The more options you have to choose from, the more potential you have to choose wrong, and if you continually choose wrong, you miss out on all the good weeks, putting you in a worse predicament than if you had just stuck with one guy."

Yes. Yes. That's exactly what's happened to me over and over again in every league except the one where I own Drew Brees.

Why's that? Because I'm not sitting Drew Brees for anything.

I'm sure most people would agree with me there. Along with Peyton Manning, he's one of only two quarterbacks who have legitimately distanced themselves from the others.

But if the secondary benefit of owning a Drew Brees -- i.e., the elimination of any potential dilemma at quarterback -- can make such a difference for my Fantasy team, why not just apply it to lesser quarterbacks, ones who don't necessarily deserve every-week status over their peers but who are productive enough to justify it in the absence of alternatives?

To be clear, I'm talking about intentionally eliminating quarterback depth to protect yourself from yourself.

Now, if you have two quarterbacks of similar value and consistently pick the higher-scoring one each week, you're obviously beyond such measures. But if you're right only half the time -- or, in my case, less than that -- the surplus is only limiting your potential output.

Maybe you still don't buy that choosing is all that difficult and view my inability to do so as nothing more than user error. But look, I don't have the same issue at running back. Not that I have a 100 percent success rate there either, but the correlation between matchup and production is strong enough to satisfy me. The problem is limited to quarterback.

And I don't know why exactly. Maybe different passing schemes work better against some teams than others while running is running is running. Maybe the flow of the game -- who gets the lead and when, which would be mostly unpredictable -- has a greater effect on the passing game than the running game. I'm just spitballing here.

Not that knowing would make a difference. Like it or not, this is the way it is, so unless you delight in chasing your tail, I say you give up on playing matchups at quarterback.

And conveniently enough, I've come to this conclusion just in time for the trade deadline in most leagues.

Not that you have to trade your excess at quarterback, of course. Keeping a spare around in case of injury could end up saving your season. But for it to work, you have to convince yourself he's just a backup, no matter how close his production is to your starter's, and affix him to your bench until you genuinely have no other choice.

Play Playoff Challenge!
Player Challenge
NEW Playoff Challenge Championship Edition offers one more way to play postseason Fantasy Football and compete for cash prizes. Join now before time runs out!
Join a new league!

I don't know about you, but I can't trust myself to do that. Keeping him around would only tempt me to make a change if I didn't like the way things went the previous week, and once you start down that path, you risk missing out on the best your starter has to offer.

Case in point: In a league where I own Russell Wilson, Philip Rivers and Case Keenum (if you think playing matchups with two is tricky, try it with three), I recently determined to stick with Wilson every week unless his matchup demanded I sit him, which clearly wasn't the case at the Falcons last week. But then I saw Rivers was facing the Broncos and thought of all the points they've given up recently and how much he'd have to throw to keep up with Peyton Manning and how smart I'd be to deviate from the plan for just one more week and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

Lo and behold, Rivers scored 14 points, Wilson scored 25, and I lost by one.

It never fails.

Now, again, it's a dilemma only if the two quarterbacks have more or less the same value. If one clearly outclasses the other, then duh, he's the one to start. But as plentiful as second-tier quarterbacks have become, chances are more than a few teams in your league have more than one, which is why I feel the need to designate priority where none exists naturally.

To that end, here are the 12 quarterbacks I'd be most willing to start the rest of the way. The goal is one per team, so if you play in a smaller league, feel free to shorten the list. I'm not saying these 12 are vastly superior to everyone else at the position, because particularly for the back half, that's simply not true. But if you can come up with a way to have one and only one on your roster without sacrificing too much in the way of value, you won't have to worry about shooting yourself in the foot anymore.

1. Peyton Manning, Broncos: You don't need me to tell you he's the best.

2. Drew Brees, Saints: If you eliminate Week 1, he's basically on par with Manning. Again, nobody's debating whether or not to start him.

3. Matthew Stafford, Lions: After a so-so first five weeks, he's distinguished himself with three-plus touchdowns in three of his last four games. A bad game for him is 250 yards and two touchdowns.

4. Tony Romo, Cowboys: Wildly inconsistent, which is the worst quality for a Fantasy quarterback, but the good games are too good to risk missing.

5. Cam Newton, Panthers: In the same boat as Romo, except the bad games are a little worse. You end up kicking yourself every time you sit him, though.

6. Nick Foles, Eagles: This is as high as I can justify ranking him with so little track record, but three of his last four starts have been nothing short of spectacular.

7. Russell Wilson, Seahawks: The tough calls begin here. Wilson has consistency going for him, but he has a bye and a game at San Francisco ahead.

8. Case Keenum, Texans: Even less of a track record than Foles, but he has been nearly flawless so far and has some nice weapons at his disposal. He also has what might be the best matchups of this group going forward.

9. Robert Griffin III, Redskins: Really hard to trust given his struggles so far, but he's coming off his best game and has terrific matchups in five of his final seven.

10. Tom Brady, Patriots: Like Griffin in that he hasn't earned much trust this year, but if his Week 9 performance is an indication of what he can do with his full allotment of weaponos, you'll be glad you held on to him.

11. Andrew Luck, Colts: Deserves more credit than I've given him thanks to the failures of the Colts' running game but doesn't have a matchup that I'd consider favorable the rest of the way (unless you count Week 17).

12. Philip Rivers, Chargers: After a strong start, he's fallen into the Ben Roethlisberger pattern of steady yardage but sparse touchdowns. Better matchups than Luck going forward, but that's not saying much.

The order here isn't as important as the narrowing down to 12. Particularly after the top six, it's too close to call, which is sort of the basis for the whole column. Even now, I'm debating whether to drop Wilson behind Brady. That upcoming bye really hurts.

The good news is you get to decide which of the 12 to keep and which to shop. Trust Luck over Griffin? Fine by me as long you commit to it. Griffin's trade value is probably as high as it's been all year. Value track record more than anything and prefer to stick with Brady over Foles? I'm sure you'll find a taker for the fresh face, as productive as he's been so far.

Of course, that goes for any of these 12, assuming you play in a 12-team league. If you have more than on your roster, then someone else doesn't have any. More likely, several don't have any because you're not the only one with more than one. I'm not saying they'll all offer fair value, but with this type of deal, the return is secondary. Ideally, you'd pair the quarterback with one of your running backs for an even better running back, but if the offer's in the ballpark and you get something you like, you should be happy to dump your problem on someone else, assuming it's actually a problem

Now, here's where I start making concessions. A time will come when Aaron Rodgers re-enters the discussion, presumably at No. 3 or 4, so keep that in mind in your negotiations. Also, keep in mind I've approached this subject from the perspective of one with excess. If you don't have any of these 12 but do have one and only one of Andy Dalton and Matt Ryan, who were the near misses, you're not so far behind that you should break up your fleet of running backs to upgrade.

Unless you're 4-6 or whatever. In that case, that fleet of running backs isn't doing you much good.

Stay in touch with the most passionate Fantasy staff in the business by following us via Twitter @CBSFantasyFB or Facebook . You can also follow Scott via Twitter @CBSScottWhite .

Want an edge in your draft? Download the Fantasy Draft Kit App.

  •  
 
 
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
COMMENTS
Conversation powered by Livefyre
 
 
Player News
Prince Amukamara set for Monday return
by Marty Gitlin | CBSSports.com
(12:39 pm ET) What was anticipated has been confirmed: Giants standout cornerback Prince Amukamara will return to practice Monday.

Amukamara has been sidelined for two weeks with a groin strain, but has now received full medical clearance.


Report: Charles Sims to be placed on IR/DTR
by Marty Gitlin | CBSSports.com
(12:36 pm ET) The Buccaneers are planning on placing rookie running back Charles Sims on IR/designated to return after undergoing ankle surgery, according to NFL Network Insider Ian Rapoport.

That move would allow the team to bring Sims back with fresh legs during the season.


Events throwing Raiders quarterback situation in doubt
by Marty Gitlin | CBSSports.com
(12:12 pm ET) Dennis Allen has seemingly softened on his stance that veteran Matt Schaub is set as the starting quarterback for the Raiders.

An elbow injury to Schaub and the continued brilliant preseason performance of rookie Derek Carr might have altered the thinking of the coach. Carr completed 11 of 13 passes for 143 yards and three touchdowns in just 22 snaps in a Thursday night defeat of Seattle.

"I really like where we're at in the quarterback room," Allen said per CSNBayarea.com. "The biggest things is that we'll have to see where Matt is when he comes in on Monday."


Chris Boswell waived; Randy Bullock earns spot with Texans
by Marty Gitlin | CBSSports.com
(12:01 pm ET) The Texans have waived rookie placekicker Chris Boswell. He had been competing with Randy Bullock for the starting spot.

Boswell made both attempts in exhibition play.


Michael Sam on bubble with roster spot decision looming
by Marty Gitlin | CBSSports.com
(11:49 am ET) Rams rookie defensive end Michael Sam continued to make a strong case for a roster spot Thursday night against Miami. He led the team with six tackles.

Sam has proclaimed himself worthy of a place on the Rams or some other NFL team. "I'm very confident I'll be playing on a NFL roster this fall," he told NFL.com. "I know I can play in this league."

His main competition on the team is undrafted rookie defensive end Ethan Westbrooks, who has also impressed. The final decision on both players is not expected to be confirmed until shortly before the cutdown time of 4 p.m. Saturday.

"I believe (Sam) can play in this league, yes," Jeff Fisher said. "As can some of the other guys on this team that had good preseasons. ... Ethan made a lot of plays every time I look. I didn't really see anything good nor bad out of (Sam), but we'll look at the tape. But he played hard, got a lot of snaps."

Sam, who has created a buzz as the first openly gay player in the NFL, will likely be placed on the practice squad if he doesn't earn a spot on the live roster.


Three-game suspension stands for Jerome Simpson
by Marty Gitlin | CBSSports.com
(11:37 am ET) Vikings wide receiver Jerome Simpson could not get a three-game suspension handed down by the NFL for a DUI reduced. The league has confirmed the suspension, per ESPN NFL Insider Adam Schefter.

Simpson contributed 48 catches for 726 yards and one touchdown last season, but faded after a strong start. He racked up nearly half of those yards in the first four games.


Personal issue keeps Percy Harvin sidelined Thursday
by Marty Gitlin | CBSSports.com
(11:30 am ET) Seahawks wide receiver Percy Harvin did not travel with the team to Oakland for the preseason finale. He was out for what was described as a personal matter that also prevented him from participating in the final two practices of the week.

Harvin has performed well in the preseason despite coming off offseason hip surgery. A hip problem limited him to just one regular season game a year ago.


Cecil Shorts: I'm ready to roll for regular season
by Marty Gitlin | CBSSports.com
(11:21 am ET) Jaguars wide receiver Cecil Shorts has declared himself "100 percent" ready for the regular season, per the Florida Times-Union.

Shorts played 15 snaps in the third preseason game and played into the fourth quarter Thursday night against Atlanta. He has described himself as rusty after returning to practice on Aug. 18. He had been out with a hamstring injury sustained in the first practice of training camp on July 25.


Aaron Dobson indicates Thursday he's on right path
by Marty Gitlin | CBSSports.com
(10:55 am ET) Patriots second-year wideout Aaron Dobson felt encouraged by his 2014 preseason debut Thursday night against the Giants.

Dobson caught three passes for 57 yards and a 33-yard touchdown in the second quarter that provided his team's first score. Not bad considering he's coming off March surgery on his left foot.

"I feel like everything is coming," Dobson told the Boston Herald. "I can't say everything is back. It's my first game back, so I've still got to feel everything out. I'm still getting my confidence, just building my confidence and growing as much as I can."

Dobson missed all of the offseason workouts and didn't begin his training camp until Aug. 11.


Charles Clay seeking to run with momentum in 2014
by Marty Gitlin | CBSSports.com
(10:43 am ET) Dolphins tight end Charles Clay emerged as one of the premier pass-catchers at his position in the NFL a year ago. He caught 69 passes for 759 yards and six touchdowns. He snagged at least five passes in seven of 16 games.

But Clay is far from satisfied. He yearns to improve his blocking, reading of coverages and reliability.

"I had drops last year that were unacceptable," Clay told the Miami Sun-Sentinel. "My standard is higher than anybody could ever have for me.

"After last year people came to me and said, 'Hey, you had this good year.' I don't look at it that way. I look at all the things I could have done better. I think about all the plays I left on the field."

Clay caught just one pass for 18 yards in the preseason after missing time with a knee injury. He has proclaimed himself ready for the regular season.


 
 
 
Rankings