It Can Only Get Better
When the lockout-shortened season began back in January, we were under the assumption that several players throughout the league were going to produce slightly more than they are currently doing. These players were trendy picks late in drafts that we believed would give us a leg up on owners that went with players who had more recognizable names and had a nagging little thing called a track record or precedence. Drafting a team is never an exact science, but it's how you handle the roster after draft that will affect your team. Is it too late to wait for that one player to get on track (Erik Johnson), or you get a bit too excited by a mere assist in one game, only to see that player disappear for the next four (Travis Zajac)? Lastly, do you drop an underperforming player with upside for a veteran who's seemingly having a resurgence (Jay Bouwmeester)? Or gamble on a rookie with a history of producing at the lower level (Tyson Barrie)?
Several players listed below have disappointed so far this season, making those that drafted them wonder when they'll start raking in points.
Brendan Smith, Detroit: With the mammoth-sized hole on Detroit's blue line left by Nicklas Lidstrom's retirement, the Red Wings were going to need production from somewhere. Brian Rafalski had retired the season before and Ian White's numbers are not ideal for fantasy owners. An uptick in Niklas Kronwall's production was to be expected but it was rookie Brendan Smith who was the trendy late-round pick in drafts during January.
Smith possesses an offensive skill-set that should allow him to reward owners that took a flier on him, but his performance on the ice has left much to be desired. Through 10 games, Smith has one assist and 12 shots on goal despite averaging 2:14 of power-play time. He's missed some time due to a shoulder injury he sustained in early February, but Smith has not stepped in to fill Detroit's void on the blue line as a secondary scorer. Smith aggravated that shoulder injury last Wednesday thanks to a hit from Los Angeles's Dustin Penner, but he did not miss any further time.
Smith jumped onto the radar of fantasy owners after posting an impressive seven points in 14 NHL contests last season and he had 20 points in 32 AHL games during the lockout. He recently turned 24, so there is potential for him to show the offensive skills that made him a first-round pick in 2007, but he can not seem to mesh with Detroit's scorers this season. If you haven't dropped him in single-season leagues, there's the possibility that he can bounce back, but Niklas Kronwall seems to have a stranglehold on the defensive scoring for Detroit, clocking in at second in the league amongst defenders with 17 points. Meanwhile, Jonathan Ericsson has seven points as well.
Roman Josi / Ryan Ellis, Nashville: The task of replacing Ryan Suter seemed less of a burden given that Nashville had both Josi and Ellis ready to step in see more ice time and opportunities to contribute offensively. It was assumed that both would be able to collectively replace some of Suter's production while Shea Weber continued his consistent, dominant scoring pace. Through a combined 44 games, Josi and Ellis have 13 points between the two of them and Weber took 10 games to notch his first point of the season.
Weber appears on his way to a strong second half with seven points over the last two weeks, but owners that gambled on either Josi or Ellis have to wonder when the production will start. Ellis joined the team with many expectations after he lit up the OHL with Windsor, winning two Memorial Cups in the process. Ellis's numbers during the lockout while playing for Milwaukee (AHL) left something to be desired though (nine points in 20 games). His six points through 22 games this NHL season have owners wondering when they will see the Ryan Ellis that can produce regularly.
Roman Josi's numbers are even more deceptive as he owns seven points on the season but four of those points came on February 25 in a win against Dallas, leaving just three points from his season's other 21 games. Josi is seeing 3:03 of power-play time, but has not been able to consistently get on the scoresheet, a common problem among this year's corps of Nashville defensemen.
Suter's impact on the Predators may have been understated as Weber and his knack to score close to 20 goals may have dominated the headlines more, but it's clear that the Preds were missing Suter and his puck-moving abilities to start the season. What's odd about Nashville this season is that their top forwards are largely unchanged from the squad that made it to the second round last season and the team is getting a great boost from Colin Wilson, who has 15 points through 22 games and five goals from Gabriel Bourque. For the most part, this group of forwards is the same set of players that allowed both Suter and Weber to crack 40 points last season: David Legwand, Patric Hornqvist, Martin Erat, Sergei Kostitsyn and Mike
Cam Fowler, Anaheim: We're not ready to anoint Fowler the new Tyler Myers, not while Tyler Myers is still being Tyler Myers, but Fowler's two-plus seasons in the NHL are trending toward a Myers-like regression. After 40 points in his rookie season, Fowler earned a respectable 29 points in 54 games his sophomore season, yet has a mere one point through 11 games in the current campaign. Fowler again has battled nagging injuries this season, missing most of February with a mysterious upper-body injury.
Anaheim's defensive production is being taken care of by the likes of Francois Beauchemin and Sheldon Souray, who have a combined 21 points in 39 games and are plus-25 as a pair. Luca Sbisa is slowly coming along with five points in 19 games. Anaheim is one of the hottest teams in the NHL not named Chicago and they're scoring with aplomb, notching 15 goals in their last three games. Anaheim's defensemen definitely have talented playmakers to pass to as Ryan Getzlaf and Corey Perry are heating up and Kyle Palmieri is establishing himself.
Fowler has returned to action, but has not registered a point in five games, five games in which the Ducks have scored quite a few goals. There's serious cause for concern as to whether his numbers will rebound, but he's young enough and has the talent to do so. He's not shooting much, with a modest 18 shots through 11 games, which could limit some of his assist numbers. The good news is that Fowler can likely be had for a waiver pickup at this point of the season and won't cost you anything to return to the scrap pile should this lack of production continue.
Jared Spurgeon, Minnesota: When Ryan Suter signed with the Wild on July 4, the focus turned to identifying who would be the No. 2 scorer in St. Paul. Currently, Suter is seeing his name on the scoresheet more regularly as he has 13 assists, (no goals yet), through 20 games including dishing out five helpers over the last five contests. Spurgeon entered this season as a candidate to pick up secondary scoring on the Minnesota blue line along with Tom Gilbert. Both are likely to be usurped statistically by Jonas Brodin and Mathew Dumba in the next few years, but Spurgeon is a player that can make an impact now.
However, Spurgeon has a goal and an assist through 11 games and, like Fowler, has battled a nagging injury which forced him to miss nine games. Spurgeon can move the puck and is a strong skater despite being one of the smaller players on the ice, notching 23 points in 70 games last season. He's another player that won't cost you anything and could benefit your roster. If he doesn't produce, you haven't spent much.
Francois Beauchemin has 13 points and a plus-12 rating through 20 games with the Ducks. (Why can't the Leafs get players like Beauchemin?)
Pittsburgh's Paul Martin has 15 points and is third in scoring through 20 games. Meanwhile, the Penguins don't seem to be playing much defense of late, as evidenced by Saturday's 7-6 overtime win over Montreal where Kris Letang grabbed four assists, putting him back at a point-per-game with 19 in 19 contests.
Oliver Ekman-Larsson appears to be taking the next step in his development as one of the league's rising two-way defensemen. OEL has 14 points and a plus-12 rating in Phoenix.
Any concerns about P.K. Subban starting slowly with Montreal after missing several weeks in a contract holdout have dissipated. The mercurial talent has 10 points through 16 games and appears to be evolving into a more complete player with a special set of skills. Of his 10 points, seven are on the power play.
Marc Staal is leading the Rangers' defensemen in scoring. Not Dan Girardi. Not Michael Del Zotto and not Ryan McDonagh. Staal has 11 points through 19 games, or one less point than Marian Gaborik to put it differently.
Dallas rookie Brenden Dillon is quietly establishing himself in multi-category leagues with six points and 33 penalty minutes spaced rather evenly throughout the season. A closer look will show Dillon has 56 hits and 26 blocked shots with a plus-5 rating through 21 games as well.
New Jersey Devils cast off Mark Fraser is leading all NHL defensemen in plus-minus with a plus-15 rating for the Leafs. He hasn't produced much offensively with a modest four assists, or the same number of points as Tyler Myers.
Erik Karlsson is still leading all NHL defensemen in shots through Saturday, despite not having played a game since February 13. He will be passed by the likes of Keith Yandle and Shea Weber this week, but Karlsson had 63 shots through 14 games, which led the entire NHL at the time of his Achilles' injury.
Washington's John Carlson is fourth among NHL defensemen in shots with 49 and has been heating up recently, with four points over the last seven games.
It's not much of a surprise, but next time you watch a New Jersey Devils game, try to identify how bad Marek Zidlicky has been. Zidlicky has eight points on the season with seven on the power play but has created more goals for the opposition than he can hope to for the Devils. He'll still see regular ice time and power-play time, but the Devils are at risk when he's on the ice. A few more poor performances and it wouldn't be a surprise to see him as a healthy scratch. He's not the worst option to use in deeper leagues, but he's not the most consistent player.
Mark Streit, Travis Hamonic and Andrew MacDonald are a combined minus-37 for the Islanders. Through 11 games, Lubomir Visnovsky has a goal and five assists, yet is somehow a plus-1 on the same team. Visnovksy, along with Brian Strait, is one of just two players with a plus rating on the Islanders.