Vogt came into this matchup against right-handed starter Nathan Karns with high expectations, and was able to find success working in his favorable platoon split. While the catcher drove in 71 runs batting in the heart of the Oakland order last year, he has more doubles (7) than RBI (6) despite reprising that role in 2016.
Nicholas has fared reasonably well in part-time duty in Texas this season. The 27-year-old, in his first Major League season, is hitting .258 with two home runs and four RBI in 31 at-bats this season while splitting time with Brian Holaday behind the plate.
Murphy was 0-for-1 with a walk in the game before getting into a heated argument with Jerry Layne while catching in the fifth. He was replaced by Kurt Suzuki, the regular starter behind the plate.
This will be a normal day off for Suzuki, as he has caught nearly all of the Twins games thus far. John Ryan Murphy will catch and bat eighth in Monday's contest.
With knuckleballer R.A. Dickey on the bump for Toronto, Martin will cede the start behind the plate to Josh Thole. Martin has historically been a decent fantasy catcher, but his .143 batting average going along with only one extra-base hit this season is reducing his value greatly. He doesn't appear to be in danger of losing his job considering Thole is only hitting .185, but it will be tough to justify a starting role for Martin in many fantasy leagues until he can turn things around at the plate.
With Robinson Chirinos missing time, Holaday was expected to garner the starting catcher role for the Rangers, but his horrific .154 batting average is keeping him from doing that. Brett Nicholas will start in his place Monday, and could get more starts going forward if Holaday continues to struggle.
Perez will take a seat for the second day in a row after beginning the season with a .148/.207/.167 slash line. In limited opportunities, his backup catcher Geovany Soto has a 1.038 OPS, so if Soto can keep this torrid pace up, Perez may be relegated to the bench more frequently.
He got the start behind the plate in place of Brian McCann, but ultimately came out in the eighth inning. Romine is batting a respectable .263 (5-for-19) and should continue seeing somewhat regular starts whenever McCann is in need of a break.
The veteran backstop had last cut down a runner on May 29, 2015, when he threw out the White Sox's J.B. Shuck. Conger, who went 1-for-3 in Sunday's game while hitting out of the ninth spot, also became the first Rays' catcher to throw out a base stealer this season. He'd made his defense a priority in recent sessions with catching coach Jamie Nelson, and the extra work paid off on the inning-ending put-out at second base. The 28-year-old's struggles in a Rays uniform have extended to his performance at the plate. He's slashing just .172/.200/.172 over his first 29 at-bats, with no extra-base hits or homers and only a single RBI.
He continues to take advantage of his opportunities, homering in consecutive starts and pushing his slash line to .344/.382/.656 in 32 at-bats on the season. With Carlos Perez hitting just .148/.207/.167 in twice the playing time, Soto should begin to see more frequent starts as long as he stays hot at the plate.